Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 3

Comparing VVIQ and Informal Visualization Tests: Instructions, Scoring, and Evidence

Recommended resources

Hello. The earlier module separated voluntary mental pictures from seeing, from knowing what something looks like, and from other kinds of imagination. This module turns to measurement. In this lesson, you will examine what a vividness questionnaire records, why an informal visualization test may give a different result, and why the cutoff chosen by a researcher matters when interpreting either result.


What a VVIQ score records

The Vividness of Visual Imagery Questionnaire, or VVIQ, asks people to deliberately form visual images and rate how vivid those images seem. In this short excerpt, researcher Adam Zeman explains the response scale and illustrates how his research group has used its scores.

Discovery of Aphantasia: How Dr. Adam Zeman Found the Missing Mind's Eye

Watch “Discovery of Aphantasia: How Dr. Adam Zeman Found the Missing Mind's Eye” from Aphantasia Network for a researcher's account of how the VVIQ is used.

Watch the VVIQ explanation. Notice the difference between a score of 16, the lowest possible total, and the wider range his group uses to recruit participants for research.

For a closer account of the questionnaire and its use in a study, read these portions of An International Estimate of the Prevalence of Differing Visual Imagery Abilities.

An international estimate of the prevalence of differing visual imagery abilities

The researchers describe what participants rate, how the scores are calculated, and why a single general rating may yield different estimates.

In the Introduction, read the opening paragraph, from the historical example and VVIQ description. Then read the Introduction's final paragraph, beginning “As visual imagery plays a role in many cognitive and behavioral tasks,” through the single-item comparison. You can skip the intervening discussion of other research findings. In Methods, read the paragraph immediately before “Procedure,” from the questionnaire description. Then, under “Data processing and analysis,” read from the classification rules. Focus on what is rated, what is added together, and which score ranges the authors chose.

The VVIQ contains 16 ratings, each from 1 to 5. A rating of 1 means no image at all; you only know what you are thinking of. A rating of 2 means a vague, dim image. At the upper end, 5 means an image reported as vivid as normal vision. The ratings cover aspects of several prompted scenes rather than a single object. In the scoring convention used in the study above, adding the ratings produces a total from 16 to 80, with lower totals indicating less vivid self-reported visual imagery.

That wording matters. The VVIQ does not measure how well someone can see an actual object, how much they know about it, or how vivid an image would look to an outside observer. It gives a structured account of conscious, voluntary visual-imagery vividness under its prompts. It does not, by itself, assess dreams, involuntary images, imagery in other senses, or a person's overall imaginative ability.

Even a total score loses some detail. A total of 32 could come from sixteen ratings of 2, but it could also come from eight ratings of 1 and eight of 3. Both totals have an average rating of 2; the reported experiences across prompts are not identical.



Why the cutoff changes the label

A questionnaire score and a category assigned to it are different things. A score of 16 means the person selected “no image at all” for all 16 items. In the international study, the authors call that score aphantasia and use 17–32 for hypophantasia, or faint imagery. In the video, Zeman describes research that uses 16–23 as its aphantasia range. Other studies have placed the boundary at 32, grouping complete absence and faint imagery together.

Thus, someone scoring 24 would fall outside a 16–23 aphantasia group but inside a 16–32 group. That is a change in the research rule, not a sudden change in the person's experience. A boundary can be useful for selecting or comparing groups without marking a sharp natural divide between neighboring scores. When you encounter a reported percentage or a claim about an “aphantasia group,” the cutoff is part of the finding.



One broad prompt versus sixteen ratings

Consider a hypothetical online test that says, “Picture an apple; if you cannot see it, you have aphantasia.” It can start reflection, but its wording leaves several things unsettled. Does “see” mean an internal impression, or something literally visible as though the apple were in the room? Is the person reporting no picture, a faint picture, or difficulty with this particular prompt? The VVIQ makes the distinction between only knowing and having a dim image explicit in its response options, and it asks about more than one scene.

A research study offers a concrete comparison. Its authors gave participants both a VVIQ and a short self-identification question about forming imagery, using a room's furniture or a friend's face as examples. The short question counted both “I cannot imagine it at all” and “I can barely imagine it” as reduced imagery.

Diversity of aphantasia revealed by multiple assessments of visual imagery, multisensory imagery, and cognitive style

This study lets you compare two ways of classifying responses from the same participants, rather than comparing unrelated online anecdotes.

Under “2.1.2. Materials,” read “2.1.2.1. VVIQ,” from the VVIQ description. Then read the first paragraph of “2.1.2.2. Self-identification of reduction in visual imagery,” beginning the short prompt and its rule. Under “2.2. Results and discussion,” read “2.2.1.1. VVIQ criteria,” from the VVIQ results, and “2.2.1.2. Self-identification of reduction in visual imagery,” from the short-prompt results. Finally, in “2.2.2. The discrepancy between criteria for VVIQ and self-identification,” read from the comparison of groups. Focus on how many participants meet both criteria, just one, or neither.

Among the 2,871 participants analyzed, 105 scored 32 or lower on the VVIQ, about 3.7%. But 347, about 12.1%, selected one of the two reduced-imagery responses to the short question. These were not simply the same people counted under a more generous label:

Short prompt: reduced imagery Short prompt: can imagine
VVIQ 32 or lower 46 59
VVIQ 33 or higher 301 2,465

The comparison shows why 12.1% cannot simply be substituted for 3.7%. The questions sample experience differently, and their classification rules differ. The short prompt uses one broad judgment and counts “barely” alongside “cannot”; the VVIQ adds ratings across specific scenes and applies a numerical boundary. The disagreement does not, on its own, prove that either method identified every person's experience correctly. Both rely on what participants report.

Nor is “online” the decisive distinction. A carefully administered VVIQ can be completed online, while a quick question can appear in a research survey. What matters is the actual prompt, response options, scoring rule, and purpose. An informal result may be a useful description of how you respond to a prompt; it is not a diagnosis, an objective measurement of imagery, or a sound basis for estimating how common aphantasia is among everyone who visits a website.



Reading a claim with the method attached

The VVIQ provides a more specified measure than an undefined “Can you visualize?” test: it names the experiences being rated, offers graded responses, and gathers reports across multiple prompts. It can support comparisons of reported voluntary visual-imagery vividness, especially when a study states its scoring convention and cutoff. Its structure does not make another person's subjective picture directly observable, and no particular cutoff settles every question about imagery.

The useful habit is to keep three statements separate: what participants reported, how researchers converted reports into scores or groups, and what conclusion those groups can support. In this lesson's comparison, different prompts and rules produced substantially different groups. In the next lesson, binocular-rivalry experiments will introduce a different kind of evidence: whether imagining a stimulus affects a later perceptual response, and what that can establish beyond a questionnaire score.