Skip to main content
Back to path

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 4

Clarifying Pronoun References

Recommended resources

Welcome back! In our last lesson, we focused on ensuring modifiers clearly point to the words they describe. We're continuing on our path toward crystal-clear prose by tackling another common source of reader confusion.

Today's lesson is about ambiguous pronoun references. A pronoun (like he, she, it, they, this, which) is a shortcut, a stand-in for a noun you've already mentioned. When it's not obvious which noun a pronoun is standing in for, your reader has to pause and puzzle it out—a cardinal sin in journalism, where clarity is king. By the end of this lesson, you'll be able to spot these ambiguities and fix them, making your writing more direct, professional, and precise.

This lesson should take you about 60 minutes.

1. Pronouns and Antecedents: The Basic Rule

Before we can fix a broken connection, we need to understand how it's supposed to work. Every pronoun refers to a noun that came before it. This noun is called the antecedent.

  • Example: The critic praised the film because she admired its cinematography.
    • Pronoun: she
    • Antecedent: critic

The fundamental rule is simple: A pronoun must refer clearly and unambiguously to a single antecedent. Problems arise when this connection is weak or confusing.

Let's watch a quick video to solidify the relationship between pronouns and their antecedents.

Pronoun Agreement — avoid the most common traps to master this grammar rule

This video from Settele Tutoring gives a straightforward definition of pronouns and antecedents.

Please watch the first minute of the video, which covers: Definitions of pronoun, antecedent, and the basic rule of agreement. An example of how to find the correct antecedent when multiple nouns are present in a sentence.

2. When the Connection Breaks: Types of Ambiguity

Pronoun ambiguity typically falls into a few common categories. Being able to recognize them is the first step to fixing them.

A great way to think about this comes from the Khan Academy. They boil pronoun clarity problems down to two main causes: either there are too many possible antecedents, or there are zero.

Pronoun Clarity | Writing and Language test | SAT | Khan Academy

This video, though framed for the SAT, offers an excellent and concise breakdown of the core issues with pronoun clarity.

Watch the following sections: Start with the introduction to understand the core problem of unclear references. Next, watch the explanation of the two main causes: too many or zero antecedents. Finally, see the simple but powerful solution proposed in "get specific".

Let's dive deeper into these issues, with a special look at a third, more subtle type of ambiguity common in professional writing.

Avoiding Unclear Pronouns - Write for Business

This article from Write for Business provides clear, real-world examples of pronoun errors.

Please read the sections titled "Too many antecedents" and "Missing antecedents" for a more detailed look at the concepts from the video.

As the video and article explain, these are the main culprits:

A. Too Many Antecedents
This happens when a pronoun could plausibly refer to more than one noun in the sentence.

  • Ambiguous: The showrunner told the lead actor that he would be written out of the next season.

    • Who is "he"? The showrunner or the actor? The meaning changes completely depending on the answer.

  • Fix 1 (Replace the pronoun): The showrunner told the lead actor that the actor would be written out of the next season.

  • Fix 2 (Rewrite the sentence): The showrunner informed the lead actor of his impending departure from the show.

B. Missing or Implied Antecedents
This occurs when the antecedent isn't explicitly stated in the sentence at all.

  • Ambiguous: In the new documentary about Oasis, they show never-before-seen footage of the band's breakup.

    • Who are "they"? The filmmakers? The documentary itself? The noun isn't there.

  • Fix: The new documentary about Oasis shows never-before-seen footage of the band's breakup.

  • Fix: In the new documentary about Oasis, the filmmakers show never-before-seen footage of the band's breakup.

C. Broad or Vague Reference
This is a more subtle error where pronouns like this, that, which, or it refer to an entire idea, clause, or sentence rather than a specific noun. This can force the reader to guess your meaning.

  • Ambiguous: The director cut 30 minutes from the film's runtime and changed the ending. This angered test audiences.
    • What angered audiences? The cuts? The new ending? Both? The reference is too broad.

To fix this, add a "summarizing noun" after the pronoun to clarify what "this" refers to.

  • Clear: The director cut 30 minutes from the film's runtime and changed the ending. This decision angered test audiences.
  • Clear: ... This new ending angered test audiences.

Let's look at a resource that specializes in this very issue.

Let's Make This Clear: Ambiguous Pronouns and How to Fix Them

This article from Antidote provides a more advanced look at broad reference and offers excellent, specific techniques for achieving clarity.

Read the article from the beginning, focusing on these parts: Start with the examples under the heading "Ambiguous Pronouns: Examples." Notice how sentences with more complex structures can create multiple targets for a pronoun. Next, read the "Techniques for Clarity" section. Pay close attention to the strategy of replacing the pronoun with a noun that summarizes the target antecedent. This is a powerful tool for professional-grade writing. Finally, review the "More examples" at the end of the article to see these fixes in action.

3. Practice: Sharpening Your Eye for Ambiguity

It's time to put this theory into practice. For each sentence below, identify the ambiguous pronoun and rewrite the sentence to make it clear. Try to use different fixing strategies.

  1. After the star and her understudy finished their rehearsal, she went to her dressing room.
  2. The script was rejected by the studio because it was too controversial.
  3. Critics are praising the film for its stunning visuals and complex characters. This is why it's a box-office success.
  4. When you’ve finished reading the article, please put it in the folder.
View suggested corrections

  1. Problem: She could be the star or the understudy.

    • Correction: After their rehearsal, the star went to her dressing room. (Replaces pronoun with noun)
    • Correction: The star went to her dressing room after finishing her rehearsal with the understudy. (Rewrites the sentence)

  2. Problem: It could refer to the script or the studio.

    • Correction: The studio rejected the script because the story was too controversial. (Replaces pronoun with a more specific noun)
    • Correction: Because the script was too controversial, it was rejected by the studio. (Sentence is reordered to make the link clearer, though still slightly weak. The first fix is better.)

  3. Problem: This is a broad reference. What is the reason for success? The praise? The visuals? The characters?

    • Correction: Critics are praising the film for its stunning visuals and complex characters. This critical acclaim is why it's a box-office success. (Adds a summarizing noun)

  4. Problem: It could be the article or the folder. While context makes it likely you mean the article, the sentence is technically ambiguous.

    • Correction: Please put the article in the folder when you've finished reading it. (Replaces pronoun with noun)

4. Final Challenge: Play the Editor

Now, let's apply your skills to a short text. The following passage is from a mock business letter, but the principles are universal. It contains four ambiguous pronoun references.

Avoiding Unclear Pronouns - Write for Business

This exercise from "Avoiding Unclear Pronouns" challenges you to find and fix multiple errors in a single text.

Read the letter under the heading "Play the Editor!" and copy it into a separate document. Then, revise it to eliminate all the unclear pronoun references.

When you're finished, compare your version to the suggested revision.

View Editor's Recommendation

Avoiding Unclear Pronouns - Write for Business

Here is the corrected version of the letter.

Review the corrected text under the "Editor's Recommendation" heading.

Analysis of the Fixes:

  • "...vibrant food scene, which provides..." -> "...vibrant food scene. Your new restaurant provides..." (The original which referred vaguely to the entire idea of opening the restaurant. The fix clarifies the subject).
  • "...he raved..." -> "...one of my Chamber colleagues raved..." (The original he was ambiguous: was it the colleague or the Chamber president?).
  • "...and it can help..." -> "Through our dynamic local business network, the Westville Chamber of Commerce can help..." (The first it was ambiguous).
  • "...It helps business owners..." -> "Our member business owners..." (The second it was also ambiguous).

Conclusion

You've now added another crucial tool to your sentence-crafting kit. By ensuring every pronoun points to a clear and specific antecedent, you eliminate mental speed bumps for your reader, allowing your ideas to flow without interruption. This isn't just about avoiding errors; it's about building trust and authority through clear, confident prose.

Key Takeaways:

  • A pronoun must always have a single, clear antecedent.
  • Ambiguity arises when there are too many possible antecedents or no clear antecedent at all.
  • Be especially careful with pronouns like this, that, which, and it. Avoid using them to refer to a whole idea; instead, add a summarizing noun (e.g., "This decision," "This trend") to provide clarity.
  • To fix an ambiguous pronoun, either replace it with the correct noun or rewrite the sentence to remove the ambiguity.

In our next lesson, we will continue our mission to trim the fat from our writing. We'll focus on identifying and revising common wordiness patterns, such as turning verbs into clunky nouns (nominalizations) and using empty filler phrases, to make your sentences more concise and powerful.