Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 2

How Expectations and Risk Can Lower Share Prices

Recommended resources

Hello. Last lesson separated a market decline’s magnitude, speed, and breadth from the less standardized label crash. Those descriptions tell you what happened to prices, not why prices changed. This lesson takes up that question: a share can fall today even if the company has reported exactly the same earnings as yesterday. The reason may lie in revised expectations about its future profits, the risk of receiving them, or the price at which investors expect to sell later.


A share price looks ahead

A share gives its owner a claim on a company’s future, not just a record of what the company earned last quarter. Suppose a company reports earnings of per share. The report does not change, but customers begin cancelling future orders. Investors may now expect weaker profits next year and offer less for a share today. The price can adjust before the weaker earnings appear in a financial statement.

The comparison is important. An earnings figure that sounds good in isolation can disappoint if investors expected more. In Session 25 (of 42): Information Trading - Earnings Reports, finance professor Aswath Damodaran explains this distinction and then shows why a company’s outlook can matter even when its reported results are strong.

Session 25 (of 42): Information Trading - Earnings Reports

Watch Aswath Damodaran’s Session 25 (of 42): Information Trading - Earnings Reports to separate reported earnings from the expectations already reflected in a share price.

Watch earnings surprises for the contrast between an earnings figure and what investors had anticipated. Then skip to future guidance, where Damodaran describes shares falling after a company reports better-than-expected earnings but offers a disappointing outlook. Focus on which information concerns the completed period and which concerns periods still to come.

There are two distinct ways expectations can change. First, a new report may reveal that current earnings differ from what investors expected; the surprise changes their assessment. Second, current earnings can remain unchanged while a new forecast, an economic development, or a change in investors’ interpretation alters expectations of future earnings. The second case is our main concern here. A share price need not wait for the next earnings report to respond.

Nor must a forecast come from company management. Investors can revise their own estimates when they learn about likely costs, competition, demand, or interest rates. They may disagree about the size of the effect, but the price at which they are willing to trade can change immediately.



Future payments and the price investors will pay now

One way to make the forward-looking idea precise is to value a hypothetical share that pays a fixed dividend every year. A dividend is cash distributed to shareholders; it is not the same thing as earnings, since a company can retain earnings rather than distribute them. For this simplified share, its estimated value depends on both the payment investors expect and the return they require for holding it.

OpenStax’s Principles of Finance 2e develops this example in its section on dividend discount models. Read the zero-growth case as a teaching model, not as a claim that real companies pay fixed dividends forever.

11.2 Dividend Discount Models (DDMs) - Principles of Finance 2e | OpenStax

Read the OpenStax account to see why an unchanged expected payment can be valued differently when investors require a different return, and why such estimates are sensitive to assumptions.

In Section 11.2, under “Zero Growth Dividend Discount Model,” begin with the fixed-dividend model. Read through the paragraph ending with changes in the required return due to perceived risk; stop before the worked question beginning “What is the intrinsic value.” Then, under “Advantages and Limitations of DDMs” and its “Concepts In Practice” subsection, locate the paragraph beginning “The sensitivity of assumptions is also a drawback.” Read the sensitivity discussion through its example of a possible 10 to 20% valuation change. Focus on what is assumed rather than treating either model output as a guaranteed trading price.

For the fixed-dividend example, the estimated value is

Suppose investors initially expect a dividend of per share every year and require a annual return. The model gives

Now keep the company’s current earnings unchanged, but suppose news leads investors to expect future annual dividends of only . At the same required return, the model gives

Nothing in that calculation says the company has already earned less. It shows why a lower forecast of future payments can support a lower price today.

This deliberately simple model has limits. Actual dividends may change, and many companies retain earnings rather than pay them out. Their retained earnings may help generate future value. More broadly, investors form estimates about future cash they might ultimately receive from ownership. Earnings forecasts help inform those estimates, but current earnings are not themselves a fixed cash payment promised to every shareholder. The model illustrates how expectations affect valuation; it does not tell us the one objectively correct market price.



Risk can change the price without changing the forecast payment

Consider the same hypothetical -per-year dividend. Suppose investors still consider the expected payment, but become less confident that the company can sustain it, or less willing to bear uncertainty. They may demand a higher prospective return to hold the share. In the model, raising the required return from to changes the estimate to

The change from to is not a prediction that an actual share would fall by that amount. It isolates a mechanism: when investors require more compensation for risk, they will generally pay less today for an otherwise unchanged stream of expected payments.

The required return can also rise because the alternatives to owning shares become more attractive. If relatively safer investments offer higher returns, a share may have to be cheaper to offer investors a sufficiently attractive expected return. A changing interest-rate outlook can therefore affect share prices without any immediate change in a company’s reported earnings.

Keep two kinds of revision separate:

What investors revise What stays fixed in the simplified comparison Why the estimated share value falls
Expected future payments Required return There is less expected future cash to value.
Required return Expected future payments Investors will pay less now for a given expected payment.

In real trading, both can change at once. News about a weakening economy might lower expected future profits and increase concern about their uncertainty. That is one reason a price move alone cannot reveal which explanation dominates.



Reading evidence without claiming more than it shows

The chart below places two related observations from 2022 side by side. Panel A shows equity market indexes fluctuating across regions. Panel B compares big-tech stock returns with forecasts of earnings-per-share growth; both series are indexed to a common starting level in April 2022. Earnings per share, or EPS, divides company earnings by the number of shares.

A Bank for International Settlements chart of regional equity-market movements (left) and big-tech stock returns alongside EPS-growth forecasts (right), indexed to 1 April 2022 = 100.

In Panel B, the forecast series and the stock-return series both weaken over the period shown. This is consistent with the idea that investors care about anticipated profitability rather than only earnings already reported. It does not demonstrate that the forecast revisions alone caused every price movement. The chart also does not establish that current earnings remained constant, or separate the effects of earnings expectations from those of changing interest rates and risk. A useful explanation respects those limits: the chart makes expectations visible, while the simplified model clarifies one reason they could matter.



Expectations about other investors matter too

Future company payments are not the only thing a shareholder considers. An investor who expects to sell before receiving many years of dividends also cares about what someone else might pay for the share at that time. If investors come to expect widespread selling soon, some may reduce the price they are willing to offer now, even though their estimate of current earnings has not changed.

This can become self-reinforcing. Imagine that investors initially expect a share to sell easily at a high price next month. A decline makes some of them suspect that others have unfavorable information or will also try to sell. They lower their offers or decide not to buy. That response can contribute to a further decline, which may strengthen the original suspicion. The price movement is real even if no one has yet established that the company’s earnings changed.

The CORE Econ chapter Assets and price bubbles explains why beliefs about resale prices can feed on observed price movements. Its account applies to rising prices and, in reverse, to sudden declines.

8.4 Assets and price bubbles – Macroeconomics

Read CORE Econ’s Assets and price bubbles for the distinction between an asset’s expected future resale price and news about the company behind a share.

In Section 8.4, “Assets and price bubbles,” start after the opening definitions with the paragraph beginning “People buy food or clothes to use them.” Read resale expectations through the paragraph ending with expectations becoming contagious. Then, later in the same section, begin at “Take the price of company shares as an example” and read the reversal to the final sentence about crashes or busts. Notice that the text discusses both genuine news about a firm and investors’ interpretations of price changes.

There is a crucial caution here. Selling in anticipation of bad news is not automatically irrational, and a falling price does not prove that investors are merely copying one another. Some sellers may have revised their estimates of future profits; others may be responding to risk; still others may infer that more selling is coming. These motives can coexist, and an outside observer may not be able to separate them from the price chart alone.

Expectations about selling also need a route into a quoted market price. A share’s displayed price commonly reflects a recent trade, not a calculation that updates automatically whenever someone changes their mind. If would-be buyers offer less or sellers accept lower bids, subsequent trades can occur at lower prices. The next lesson will examine that trading mechanism more closely, including why the same sell order can move the price much further when few buyers are ready to take the other side.



Key takeaways

A share price looks beyond current earnings. It can fall because investors expect lower future payments, require more return to bear risk, or expect other investors to sell or pay less later. These explanations are distinct, although several can operate together. A reported earnings number may be unchanged while forecasts and willingness to trade change substantially.

The lesson’s models and chart help explain possibilities, not diagnose a particular price move with certainty. Next, you will look inside a simple order book to see how changed willingness to buy or sell becomes an actual price change—and why low liquidity can magnify it.