Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 5

Approval Requirements for Gubernatorial Appointments

Recommended resources

Hello. Earlier modules considered how the governor works with the legislature on laws and spending. This module turns to appointments: choosing someone for an office is an executive power, but the approval required depends on which office is being filled. In this lesson, you will distinguish appointments to executive agency leadership from appointments that fill vacancies in independently elected statewide offices. The next lesson will address judges, whose selection rules are different again.


One word, two kinds of office

Suppose the governor selects a Director of Health Care Services. Now suppose the elected State Treasurer leaves office before the term ends. Both situations involve a gubernatorial choice, but they do not have the same approval rule.

An executive agency leader directs part of state administration. State law specifies which of these gubernatorial appointments require confirmation by the State Senate. By contrast, the Treasurer ordinarily holds an office filled by voters. A midterm vacancy does not turn that office into a position the governor can fill alone: the California Constitution requires confirmation by both legislative houses.

The useful starting point is therefore not “Does the governor appoint this person?” but “What kind of office is this, and what rule governs this appointment?”



Executive leadership: check the statute for Senate confirmation

California Government Code sections 1320–1323 set out rules for nominations sent to the Senate and identify a number of appointments subject to Senate confirmation. Read the provisions as a way to identify the rule, rather than trying to memorize the long list of offices.

Codes Display Text

Read the California Government Code’s provisions on nominations by the governor to see how a statutory Senate-confirmation requirement is expressed.

In “Article 2. Nominations by Governor,” read sections 1320–1321, from written nominations through the notice sent after Senate concurrence. Then read sections 1322–1323, from the confirmation rules. Focus on the opening sentence of section 1322, its examples of department directors, and section 1323’s statement that its rule does not apply where the Constitution provides the manner of appointment.

Section 1322 expressly includes, among others, the Director of Health Care Services and the Director of Social Services. For these examples, the governor’s selection is subject to Senate confirmation. The Assembly does not gain a confirmation vote simply because it is the other house of the legislature.

There are two qualifications worth keeping in view. First, section 1322 says its list is in addition to other statutory Senate-confirmation requirements, and section 1323 covers another specified category. The list in one section is not a complete map of every state appointment. Second, section 1323 excludes offices whose manner of appointment is provided for in the Constitution. That matters when we turn to elected statewide offices: their vacancy rule comes from a different source and requires a different set of approvals.

For a particular agency position, the sound method is to identify the office and check its governing law. It is not safe to assume either that every agency employee needs Senate confirmation or that no executive appointment needs legislative approval.



An elected statewide office: both houses participate

The Treasurer and Attorney General are examples of independently elected statewide officers. Voters normally choose who holds these offices; the governor does not appoint their occupants as ordinary agency leaders. California nevertheless needs a way to fill a vacancy before the next regular election. For the offices specified in Article V, section 5(b) of the California Constitution, the governor nominates a replacement, who takes office upon confirmation by a majority of the membership of the Senate and the Assembly.

The election-office guide below explains that rule and an important exception to the assumption that every statewide vacancy is filled by a gubernatorial nominee.

Guide to Filling a Vacancy in Elective Office

Read the guide’s discussion of vacancies in state constitutional offices to compare the governor’s role with the roles of the two legislative houses.

On printed pages 11–12, find “VACANCIES IN STATE CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICES.” Under “GOVERNOR,” read from governor succession. Then, under “OTHER STATE CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICES,” read from the vacancy rule. Focus on the named offices, the majority required in each house, and the paragraph describing what happens if the nomination is neither confirmed nor refused within the specified period.

The constitutional list includes the Lieutenant Governor, Secretary of State, Controller, Treasurer, Attorney General, Superintendent of Public Instruction, and members of the State Board of Equalization. For a vacancy in one of these offices, Senate confirmation alone is insufficient. A majority of the membership of each house must confirm the nominee; this is not merely a majority of whoever happens to be present for a vote. The confirmed person serves the balance of the unexpired term, rather than beginning a new full term.

The guide also notes a time limit on legislative consideration. If the nominee is neither confirmed nor refused confirmation by both houses within 90 days of submission, the nominee takes office as though confirmed. If that period ends during a legislative recess, the deadline is extended as specified in the rule. This is a defined default, not permission for the governor to disregard a legislative refusal.

Two nearby cases prevent overgeneralization. A vacancy in the governor’s own office is filled through succession: the Lieutenant Governor becomes governor, rather than being nominated and confirmed. The guide also identifies the Insurance Commissioner as an elected-office vacancy for which a separate statute requires legislative confirmation in the same manner as the constitutional rule. Thus, “independently elected” tells you to look for a vacancy rule; the governing constitutional or statutory provision tells you its precise terms.



Choosing the correct approval rule

The contrast can be summarized without treating all gubernatorial selections as interchangeable:

Office being filled Governor’s role Approval or other controlling rule
Director of Health Care Services or Director of Social Services Appoints a leader named in Government Code section 1322 Senate confirmation
Vacant elected office of Treasurer or Attorney General Nominates someone for the remainder of the term Majority of the Senate membership and majority of the Assembly membership, subject to the specified 90-day rule
Vacant office of Governor No replacement nominee for legislative confirmation Lieutenant Governor succeeds under the succession rule

Notice what the comparison says about limits on executive power. The governor has a substantial role in selecting people, but cannot convert an elected office into an ordinary executive appointment. Nor can the governor substitute one house’s approval for two when the Constitution requires both. Conversely, it would be inaccurate to impose the two-house vacancy rule on an agency director whose appointment statute calls for Senate confirmation.



Key takeaways

Identify the office before identifying the approval. Statutes require Senate confirmation for specified executive leadership appointments, including the two department-director examples above. Vacancies in listed independently elected statewide offices follow a distinct constitutional process: gubernatorial nomination and confirmation by majorities of both houses, with a specified rule for legislative inaction. A vacancy in the governor’s office instead follows succession.

The next lesson applies the same habit of checking the office’s governing rule to judges, distinguishing superior court vacancies from appointments to California’s appellate courts.