Hello. Last lesson followed California’s budget from the governor’s proposal through legislative passage and enactment. Now consider a narrower question: once the Legislature has passed a spending bill, how much of it may the governor change while approving the rest? This lesson focuses on the line-item veto—the power to reduce or eliminate an appropriation—and on the Legislature’s power to reverse that decision.
A limited exception to the whole-bill choice
Ordinarily, a governor faced with a bill may approve it or veto it as a whole. California’s Constitution makes an exception for spending: the governor may reduce or eliminate one or more items of appropriation while approving other portions of the bill. This can prevent a particular expenditure from taking effect without rejecting every other provision.
The exception is deliberately narrow. It concerns items of appropriation, not any passage the governor dislikes. The Constitution also requires the governor to identify the affected items and give reasons. Read the governing text before considering the boundary.
Constitution of California—Article IV 207
Read the California Constitution’s rules for the ordinary veto and for reductions or eliminations of appropriations. They establish both the governor’s power and the Legislature’s response.
In Section 10(a), on the page preceding the printed page numbered 216, read from “Each bill passed by the Legislature shall be presented to the Governor” through the sentence specifying the vote needed to overcome a veto: the whole-bill rule. Then find Section 10(e) on printed page 216. Read its entire paragraph, beginning “The Governor may reduce or eliminate one or more items” and ending “in the same manner as bills”: the item-veto rule. Pay particular attention to the verbs reduce and eliminate, and to the requirement that affected items be reconsidered separately.
The word reduce permits a smaller appropriation; eliminate permits removing it altogether. Neither word grants the governor a general editing power. If a bill appropriates million for a stated purpose, reducing that item to million is the kind of action Section 10(e) authorizes. Striking the item would eliminate that appropriation. In either case, the governor must provide the constitutional statement of the affected item and reasons.
Identify the item before judging the veto
An appropriation sets aside public money for a specified purpose. To assess a proposed line-item veto, first locate the spending authority in the bill: what money is being appropriated, and for what purpose? Then ask whether the governor’s proposed change merely makes that appropriation smaller or removes it.
For example, suppose a budget bill contains an item appropriating million for a department’s services. The governor could reduce that item to million. But the item-veto power would not let the governor rewrite it as “ million, provided the department stops offering one particular service.” That addition changes the terms of the law rather than merely reducing its appropriation. Nor could the governor use an item veto to move the removed million into a different program: reducing spending is not authority to create or increase another appropriation.
The distinction is especially important when a program’s rules and its funding appear in different provisions. A rule directing an agency to provide a benefit may cost money to carry out, but its cost alone does not make the rule an appropriation. The governor may have grounds to veto a bill containing an unwanted rule as a whole; the item-veto exception does not permit striking just that rule while approving the bill’s remainder.
The boundary in a California Supreme Court decision
Harbor v. Deukmejian illustrates why the distinction matters. The governor reduced a broad budget appropriation and also attempted to veto a provision in a separate bill concerning how benefits would be provided. The court distinguished the funding item from the substantive direction to the agency.
Read the California Supreme Court’s explanation of why a power to reject an appropriation is not a power to select and rewrite substantive policy. The decision supplies a useful test for less obvious examples.
Under “Validity of the Governor’s Veto,” first read the discussion on printed page 1086 beginning “The limitation is firmly rooted in our constitutional system” and ending with the warning about affirmatively legislating: the constitutional boundary. Then move to the analysis marked “[2],” beginning on the page before printed page 1090. Read from “The Governor did not veto Bill 1379” through the conclusion on printed page 1091 that the attempted exercise lacked authority: the court’s application. Focus on why the court treats the direction to provide benefits differently from the budget’s appropriation, even though providing those benefits requires money. This older opinion refers to a former subdivision number for the item veto; the constitutional text you just read places the rule in Section 10(e).
The court’s practical point is subtle. Where the Legislature makes a lump-sum appropriation for a purpose, the governor may reduce or eliminate that appropriation. The governor cannot, however, split the lump sum into invented sub-items, assign a particular amount to a disliked policy, and use that calculation to veto a separate substantive provision. A funding cut may make a policy harder to carry out; it does not, by itself, repeal the policy.
A reliable way to analyze a proposed action is therefore to separate two questions:
- What is the legal target? Is it an actual item setting aside money, or a rule about what an agency must do?
- What is the legal effect? Does the governor only lower or remove the item’s funding, or attempt to add conditions, redirect money, or delete substantive law?
The label “budget-related” does not answer either question. The provision’s function does.
How the Legislature can restore an item
An item veto is a check on legislative spending, not necessarily the final word. Under Section 10(e), each reduced or eliminated item is reconsidered separately. The Legislature can pass an affected item over the governor’s veto in the same manner as it can override a whole-bill veto: a recorded roll-call vote with two-thirds of the membership of each house concurring. That threshold applies even though the governor approved the rest of the bill.
Return to the million appropriation reduced to million. If both houses achieve the required two-thirds vote to override the reduction, the item can take effect at the amount the Legislature originally passed. If they do not, the reduction stands; the remainder of the approved bill is not undone merely because legislators considered an override. The Legislature could instead pursue later legislation to provide funding, but that would be a new bill subject to its own passage and gubernatorial consideration—not an automatic restoration by a simple majority.
This separates two stages that are easy to confuse. Legislators decide what funding to put in the bill they pass. After the governor reduces or eliminates an item, restoring that vetoed item requires the constitutional override vote.
Takeaways
California’s governor may approve most of a bill while reducing or eliminating an actual item of appropriation. The governor must identify the affected item and give reasons, and cannot use the item veto to write new spending conditions, redirect funds, or strike substantive policy simply because that policy costs money. The Legislature can restore a reduced or eliminated item by a separate override vote requiring two-thirds of the membership of each house.
The next module turns to appointments and courts, including how courts can decide whether a governor’s action stayed within legal limits.