Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 11

Evaluating Creativity Claims in Aphantasia

Recommended resources

Aphantasia concerns the ability to form voluntary mental pictures, not the broader ability to generate ideas or make things. That distinction becomes especially important when a claim about aphantasia turns into a claim about creativity.

This module examines two kinds of overreach: treating an imagery difference as a verdict on someone’s abilities, and treating an interesting finding as proof of a stereotype. In this lesson, you will compare three kinds of evidence about creativity—performance on short tasks, patterns in occupations, and examples of creative work. The next lesson will use those distinctions to check claims against their original sources.


Creativity is broader than visualization

A mental picture can be useful during creative work. Someone designing a scene might picture a composition before drawing it. But the finished work can also develop through sketches, references, revision, verbal ideas, spatial planning, or experimentation with materials. A tool that helps some people create is not necessarily a prerequisite for creating. Equally, finding that a person can create without that tool does not tell us whether the tool affects anyone’s process.

Researchers face a measurement problem here. “Creativity” might mean generating many possibilities, finding an unusual connection, producing a useful invention, or developing a work of art over months. No brief laboratory task captures all of those achievements. A good interpretation therefore names the particular activity measured before making a broader claim.

Joel Pearson describes two such tasks and presents early group results. Watch the creativity segment rather than treating its conclusions as a settled answer.

Joel Pearson Extreme Imagery 2021 (Aphantasia and mental imagery)

In “Joel Pearson Extreme Imagery 2021,” on The Neuro Futurist with Prof Joel Pearson, Pearson explains why creativity is difficult to define and presents preliminary results from two tasks. Watch for both the results and his warning about who volunteered for the research.

Watch the creativity segment. The alternative uses task begins when Pearson introduces uses for a brick, paperclip, or paper; the remote associates task appears near the end, when he describes finding a word connecting three others. Pay particular attention to his discussion of self-selection after the alternative uses results.

In the alternative uses task, participants list possible uses for an everyday object within a time limit. Responses can be assessed in several ways. Fluency concerns how many ideas are produced; flexibility concerns the variety of kinds of ideas; originality concerns how unusual the ideas are, as judged here by raters. These are related, but they are not interchangeable. Producing more ideas, for example, creates more opportunities to produce an unusual one. Neither an originality rating nor an idea count tells us whether someone could complete a compelling painting, design, or long-term project.

Pearson reports modestly higher scores for the aphantasia group on fluency, flexibility, and originality in the results he shows. He also reports that the group performed better on a remote associates task, which requires finding a word linking three given words. That task samples a different skill: spotting a constrained verbal connection rather than generating many uses. The results are interesting precisely because they do not show an obvious disadvantage on these tasks for the volunteers with aphantasia.

The scope of that conclusion matters. In the presentation, Pearson explains that people in the aphantasia group had learned about the phenomenon and made contact to participate. Volunteers who seek out a study may differ from people who do not, in ways that also affect task performance. His account does not establish that aphantasia causes higher creativity, that the groups would differ in a representative population, or that these scores measure every kind of creative work. His prediction that future studies will likewise find no disadvantage is a prediction, not a result already demonstrated.

The careful reading is narrower and still useful: these preliminary task results challenge the claim that an absence of voluntary visual imagery necessarily prevents idea generation or verbal insight. They do not support replacing that stereotype with “people with aphantasia are more creative.”



Occupations show a pattern, not a mechanism

Another kind of evidence asks where people work. A study discussed in the following paper reports an association between imagery extremes and occupational categories. Read the account for how the participants came to researchers, as well as for the occupational finding itself.

Behavioral and Neural Signatures of Visual Imagery Vividness Extremes: Aphantasia versus Hyperphantasia

Read the paper’s opening account of questionnaire findings, focusing on recruitment and the comparison of reported occupations.

In the opening background paragraphs, find the paragraph beginning “Our description of” aphantasia in 2015. Within it, read the survey account, continuing through the sentence that ends with “creative” professions. Notice that this is an account of respondents who contacted the researchers, not a comparison of creative-task scores.

The reported pattern was that respondents with aphantasia were more likely to work in scientific or mathematical domains, while respondents with hyperphantasia more often reported occupations categorized as “creative.” That is an occupational association among the people studied. It is not a direct test of their ability to generate ideas, make art, or solve problems.

Several steps separate a person’s imagery experience from their job title. Career choices can reflect interests, training, opportunities, and the way a study groups occupations. The recruitment method matters too: people who contact researchers after hearing about imagery extremes may not represent everyone at those extremes. An occupational association alone cannot show that imagery caused a career choice, or that someone in one category could not succeed in another.

The category “creative profession” also deserves care. It can be useful for describing a survey result, but it does not establish that creativity occurs only within those jobs. Conversely, working in a profession labeled creative does not provide a scored measure of an individual’s creative ability. Occupation describes what someone does for work; task performance describes what someone did under specified conditions. Those are different observations, even when both are relevant to the same discussion.



Individual work rules out an absolute barrier

An individual example supplies a third kind of evidence. In this short segment, Adam Zeman discusses occupational patterns and shows work by artists who report aphantasia.

Blind Mind's Eye - The Science of Aphantasia with Dr. Adam Zeman

In “Blind Mind’s Eye - The Science of Aphantasia,” from Aphantasia Network, Adam Zeman moves from career associations to examples of visual art made by people with aphantasia. The closing remark states the distinction between visualization and imagination.

Watch careers and art for the occupational claim and the examples of visual creative work. Then watch the distinction between lacking mental pictures and lacking the broader capacity to imagine.

An artist who produces visual work while reporting aphantasia is a strong counterexample to the absolute claim “Nobody without mental pictures can make visual art.” One counterexample is enough to refute a universal impossibility claim. It is not enough to estimate how common visual artists are among people with aphantasia, compare their average output with another group’s, or establish how they create.

The same distinction applies to anecdotes about process. An account of using references or discovering a composition while drawing can illuminate one person’s method. It should not be turned into a rule that every artist with aphantasia works that way. Creative work admits multiple routes, and the absence of an internal picture does not, by itself, specify which route any individual takes.

A drawing study provides a useful check against another tempting inference. If a group puts fewer objects into drawings made from memory, it would be a mistake to call that a creativity score. Reconstructing details of a previously seen room and inventing or developing an artwork impose different demands. The study’s art-related checks help keep those demands separate.

Quantifying Aphantasia through drawing: Those without visual imagery show deficits in object but not spatial memory

Read the drawing study’s checks on participants’ experience with art. They help distinguish memory-drawing results from claims about artistic ability.

In the Results section, locate the paragraph beginning “Third, we investigated whether aphantasic and control participants reported different levels of comfort or familiarity with art.” Read the art checks through its final sentence. Focus on the self-ratings, past art classes, reported occupations, and the authors’ warning not to over-interpret the occupational contrast.

Participants with and without aphantasia did not show a statistically significant difference in self-rated artistic ability in this sample, and similar proportions reported having taken art classes. Some participants with aphantasia reported working in art-related fields. The authors explicitly caution against over-interpreting the occupational difference because recruiting a broad range of occupations was not the study’s aim.

These observations counter a casual story that poorer memory drawings simply reveal a lack of interest in, or exposure to, art. They do not amount to a controlled comparison of artistic creativity. Self-ratings are not independently judged artworks; a past class is not a creativity test; and failing to detect a group difference does not prove the groups identical in every respect. The drawing result is best kept attached to its task: recalling object information from seen scenes, not inventing new ones.



Putting the three kinds of evidence together

The findings can look contradictory if they are all compressed into the word “creative.” The occupational survey describes where certain respondents worked. Pearson’s tasks describe how certain volunteers performed on brief idea-generation and word-connection tasks. Examples of artists describe what particular people have made. Each can be true without settling the others.

Evidence What it can support What it cannot establish alone
Creative-task results Performance on the specific task, in the tested sample Overall creative ability, career prospects, or a causal effect of imagery
Occupational reports A pattern in reported work among respondents Creative ability, or why people entered those occupations
Individual creative work That such work is possible for someone with aphantasia How typical that person is, or a group-wide comparison

This separation also makes claims easier to calibrate. “Aphantasia makes visual art impossible” is contradicted by examples of visual artists with aphantasia. “Aphantasia improves creativity” goes beyond the preliminary task results, particularly given the recruitment concern. “People with hyperphantasia more often reported creative professions in this survey” preserves both the finding and its boundary. None of those judgments requires treating all mental experiences—or all creative practices—as alike.

The most defensible overall conclusion is that voluntary visual imagery is one possible resource for creative work, not a synonym for creativity or a demonstrated requirement for it. Research can examine whether imagery relates to particular tasks or choices, but it must measure those outcomes rather than infer them from the vividness of someone’s mind’s eye.



Conclusion

Creativity claims become more precise when you identify what was observed: a task score, a reported occupation, or an individual work. The task evidence presented here does not show a creativity deficit in the tested aphantasia group, but its preliminary results and self-selected participants limit broader conclusions. Occupational associations do not measure ability or establish cause. Individual artists decisively challenge claims of impossibility without standing in for an entire population.

The next lesson turns this distinction into a source-checking method: tracing an online claim back to what researchers actually measured, then separating that finding from speculation and stereotypes.