Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 1

Distinguishing Visual Imagery from Perception and Non-Visual Imagination

Recommended resources

Mental pictures can feel so familiar—or so unfamiliar—that it is easy to assume everyone means the same thing by “visualize.” This course examines that variation, then looks at how researchers measure it and what the evidence says about memory, dreaming, and creativity. This first lesson establishes a distinction needed throughout: seeing something, picturing it when it is absent, knowing what it looks like, and imagining something are not the same activity.

Allow about 40 minutes. The short clips and readings are there to anchor the distinctions in descriptions and research; the explanations around them will help you interpret what each example does and does not show.


Seeing and picturing are different experiences

Suppose an apple is on a table in front of you. Light from it reaches your eyes: you can look at its color and shape, turn it, and discover a mark you had not noticed. That is visual perception. Now suppose the apple is gone and you deliberately try to picture it. If an image comes to mind, that is voluntary visual imagery. Its source is not a currently visible apple, even if you remember a real one.

A mental picture need not resemble a photograph or appear projected onto the backs of your eyelids. For many people it is faint, incomplete, or fleeting. The relevant contrast is between having some visual experience of the absent apple and thinking about the apple without that experience.

Blind Mind's Eye - The Science of Aphantasia with Dr. Adam Zeman

Watch the opening imagery example in “Blind Mind's Eye,” presented by researcher Adam Zeman on Aphantasia Network. It gives language for differences that can otherwise be difficult to describe.

Watch the sunrise example, from the invitation to picture a sunrise through the description of a broad range of responses. Focus on the difference between a picture coming to mind and having only the concept of what was described. Treat this as an illustration, not a diagnostic test.

Notice what the invitation required: not recognizing a sunrise in a photograph, and not knowing that the sun appears near a horizon, but intentionally calling up a visual experience when the scene was not present. In this course, aphantasia will usually mean a reported absence of that voluntary visual imagery. The term’s boundaries are not perfectly uniform across research, so it is worth specifying visual and voluntary rather than assuming every kind of mental experience is absent.

A Systematic Review of Aphantasia: Concept, Measurement, Neural Basis, and Theory Development

Read the opening conceptual discussion of this systematic review to see why researchers do not always use “aphantasia” in precisely the same way.

In the discussion immediately before “4. Aphantasia and Cognitive Processing,” read the opening paragraph. Stop at the discussion of whether definitions specify voluntary imagery; leave the subsequent measurement and prevalence paragraphs for later lessons. Focus on the two questions of scope: whether the term refers only to visual imagery, and whether it refers specifically to imagery produced at will.

This qualification matters because an everyday sentence such as “I cannot see it in my mind” is informative about someone’s experience, but does not by itself settle every question about other senses or imagery that arises unbidden. Those variations come next in the course. For now, keep the target narrow: a deliberate attempt to form a mental picture.



Knowing an appearance without picturing it

It may seem that if you know what an apple looks like, you must be seeing one internally. But knowledge and imagery can come apart. You might know that a particular chair is blue, has wooden legs, and stands beside a window without experiencing a picture of it. You can also sometimes identify the chair immediately when you see it again. Neither the description nor the recognition, by itself, tells us whether you could voluntarily picture it beforehand.

One account in Zeman’s presentation makes this distinction unusually clear. It is a report from an individual, not a claim that everyone with aphantasia has the same memory experience.

Blind Mind's Eye - The Science of Aphantasia with Dr. Adam Zeman

Return to Zeman’s presentation for an account of remembering visual information without experiencing it as a mental picture.

Watch the recollection account, beginning with the question about picturing familiar locations. Attend to the contrast the speaker draws between information that remains available to him and mental visualization that does not.

The phrase “I just know” can cover several things: recalling a fact, retaining a sense of where things are, or recognizing something when it appears. These are not interchangeable with one another, but none should automatically be treated as evidence of a conscious mental picture.

A room-drawing study offers a useful check against another mistaken inference: that difficulty drawing from memory must mean difficulty seeing or drawing while looking. The study compared these tasks rather than treating all drawing as one ability.

Can’t draw a mental picture? Aphantasia causes blind spots in the mind’s eye | The University of Chicago Division of the Social Sciences

Read Max Witynski’s account for the University of Chicago Division of the Social Sciences of a room-drawing study. Here its value is the contrast between drawing from memory, copying a visible photograph, and recognizing a photograph.

Under “Study examines rare condition, which causes a lack of visual memory,” find the paragraph beginning “For the study.” Read the task and findings, ending with the comparison of remembered object locations and details. Then continue to copying and recognition, from the paragraph about copying photographs through the final paragraph about recognizing rooms and familiar people. Focus on which tasks required the photograph to be present and which did not.

The copying condition is particularly important here. Participants could draw while looking at the photographs; the reported difference concerned what they produced without the photograph. The recognition result makes a related point: identifying a previously seen room when shown it again is different from summoning its appearance at will. These findings do not mean that every aspect of memory is identical across groups—a later lesson will examine the memory evidence more carefully. They do show why “cannot picture it” should not be paraphrased as “cannot see it” or “cannot know what it looks like.”



Imagination is broader than a mental picture

Consider inventing a story in which the apple on the table is the only object that remains unchanged while everything around it transforms. You might see the scene in your mind, but you could also develop it through words, relationships between events, or ideas about what the change means. Visual imagery can be one way to imagine; it is not a requirement for imagining.

Likewise, planning how furniture might fit in a room need not feel like inspecting an internal photograph. Someone could reason about positions and distances while picturing little or nothing. Describing such thinking as “nonvisual” tells us about its experienced form, not that it lacks invention or complexity.

Blind Mind's Eye - The Science of Aphantasia with Dr. Adam Zeman

Zeman closes part of his presentation by separating mental imagery from the wider capacity to think imaginatively.

Watch imagery and imagination, beginning with his discussion of ways to represent absent objects and ending as he distinguishes imagery from imagination. Focus on the distinction itself, rather than reading the example as proof that imagery never affects any creative task.

A useful way to hold the four ideas apart is to ask what is doing the work in each case. When the apple is in front of you, its visible features are available through perception. When you intentionally experience an absent apple as a picture, that is voluntary visual imagery. When you can state its features or identify it on sight, that demonstrates knowledge or recognition, which does not establish that you pictured it. When you invent what might happen to it, that is imagination, which may use pictures but need not.

The distinction avoids two opposite errors. A report of no mental pictures should not be dismissed because the person can recognize objects or invent stories. Equally, successful recognition or creative work should not be taken as proof that the person secretly experiences visual imagery. Each observation speaks to a different part of mental life.



Closing perspective

Aphantasia concerns an aspect of experience, not an all-purpose absence of seeing, knowing, remembering, or imagining. The most precise starting question for this course is whether a person can voluntarily experience a visual image of something that is not currently in view. Answers can differ without making other abilities impossible.

The next lesson will widen this picture. It will treat vividness, imagery produced deliberately versus imagery that arises on its own, and imagery in different senses as separate dimensions—rather than forcing every mind into a single “visualizer” or “nonvisualizer” category.