Welcome back. The previous lesson separated a federal constitutional claim of partisan gerrymandering, which Rucho says federal courts cannot resolve, from other redistricting claims that federal courts can hear. This lesson takes up one of those other claims: that a state used race as the predominant factor in drawing a district, contrary to the Equal Protection Clause.
Race and party affiliation can be closely correlated in an electorate. That makes a map’s partisan effects important context, but not a substitute for evidence about how the lines were chosen. You will use that distinction to work through a short hypothetical and see when a racial-gerrymandering claim triggers strict scrutiny.
The question Equal Protection asks
An Equal Protection racial-gerrymandering claim concerns the state’s use of race in constructing a challenged district. It is not simply a claim that a district has an unusual shape, elects a candidate of a particular party, or contains many voters from one racial group.
The threshold question is whether race predominated: did the mapmakers give racial considerations priority over other districting considerations in deciding where the district’s lines would go? Traditional considerations include compactness, keeping a district contiguous, and respecting political subdivision boundaries. A departure from those practices may be evidence, but a challenger does not have to prove an oddly shaped district as a mandatory first step.
If the challenger establishes racial predominance, the state must satisfy strict scrutiny. It must show a compelling governmental interest for the race-based districting and that its use of race was narrowly tailored to that interest. Strict scrutiny is demanding, but finding racial predominance does not by itself finish the case: the state has an opportunity to justify what it did.
Read the two short passages below for the governing framework. The first states the threshold and scrutiny rule; the second adds important cautions about proof.
Read the Constitution Annotated essay from the Library of Congress for its account of the Equal Protection racial-gerrymandering framework. Focus on what triggers strict scrutiny before considering whether the state can satisfy it.
In “Racial Vote Dilution and Racial Gerrymandering,” find the paragraph beginning “In addition to the VRA, however.” Read the scrutiny rule, stopping before the discussion of Section 2 that follows it. Then find the paragraph beginning “In a series of cases.” Read the proof cautions through its end. Notice the requirements for district-specific analysis and for overcoming the presumption of legislative good faith.
Two qualifications matter when applying that reading. First, predominance is assessed district by district, not by assigning one motive to the entire statewide map. Second, legislators are entitled to a presumption of good faith; a challenger bears the burden of establishing the improper use of race. Neither qualification makes direct evidence irrelevant. Instructions to select voters by race, racial targets applied to individual districts, and records showing which data mapmakers consulted can be highly informative.
When race and party point to the same voters
Suppose an area’s voters from a particular racial group also tend to support Party P. Moving those voters across a district line could help Party P, change the district’s racial composition, or both. The resulting map alone may not tell you which consideration drove the line. As in the earlier lesson on residential clustering, a pattern in the finished map is not automatically proof of deliberate manipulation.
Evidence about decision-making helps disentangle the explanations. Compare these possibilities:
- A mapmaker instructs staff to reach a specified racial percentage and moves blocks to meet it despite conflicting geographic objectives. That is strong evidence that race influenced, and perhaps predominated in, the district’s design.
- A mapmaker uses past party-vote totals to protect an incumbent. The resulting district also changes racially because party support and race are correlated there. That racial change, without more, does not establish racial predominance.
- Staff records reveal both racial and party data on their screens. The presence of both is relevant, but the court still needs to determine which considerations actually controlled the challenged lines.
An alternative map can sometimes sharpen the comparison. For example, a map that achieves the state’s stated partisan objective while making different racial choices may help test a claim that the enacted racial choices were unavoidable. It is a way to provide evidence, not a universal requirement that every racial-gerrymandering challenger submit an alternative map. Direct statements and other records may also establish what drove the lines.
Cooper v. Harris illustrates why this distinction can be contested. Read it as an account of a 2017 case, rather than as a complete statement of what the Voting Rights Act requires after later decisions.
Read Oyez’s account of Cooper v. Harris for a concrete example of a racial target, an asserted Voting Rights Act justification, and the evidence a court considered.
Under “Facts of the case,” read the redistricting facts, ending with the district court’s finding. Then go to “Conclusion” and read the Court’s reasoning. Focus on the difference between the state’s stated reason for using race and its evidence that such use was needed.
The state’s reference to a “50% plus one” Black voting-age-population target was part of the dispute. It should not be carried forward as a rule that every district must meet a fixed racial percentage. Nor does saying “the Voting Rights Act required it” establish a compelling interest without a sound basis for that assertion. The details of present-day Section 2 obligations belong to the next lesson; for now, keep the Equal Protection inquiry focused on why and how this particular district was drawn.
A worked hypothetical: District 3
A state redraws four equal-population districts. Party P’s legislators want to protect a Party P incumbent outside District 3. A proposed map moves several neighborhoods into District 3, increasing its minority voting-age population from 43% to 55%. The move splits a city and a long-established neighborhood. Because many of the moved voters support Party Q, the change also improves Party P’s prospects in another district.
The available records include a staff instruction: “District 3 must reach 55% minority voting-age population, even if that means splitting the city.” Planners used a racial-data layer to select the blocks moved into District 3. The state responds that its real objective was partisan advantage and that it also believed the Voting Rights Act required a 55% district. So far, it offers no district-specific analysis supporting that asserted requirement.
Start with predominance, not with whether the map is fair. The partisan benefit is real, but it does not erase the staff instruction. A numerical racial target, an instruction to meet it despite the city boundary, and records of selecting blocks by race together provide substantial evidence that race controlled the construction of District 3. The city split reinforces that inference. Its shape, however, is not an indispensable element of the claim: the instruction and selection records would still matter if the resulting district looked compact.
The state’s partisan explanation deserves examination rather than automatic rejection. The court would consider all the evidence under the applicable burden and presumption of legislative good faith. On these stipulated facts, though, saying “we also wanted a partisan advantage” does not answer evidence that planners made racial composition the controlling criterion for District 3’s lines. The proper conclusion at this stage is that there is strong evidence of racial predominance, not that every district on the map has been proved unlawful.
Then apply strict scrutiny. Compliance with a valid Voting Rights Act obligation could potentially supply a compelling interest. But the state has identified no analysis supporting its belief that this district needed a 55% minority voting-age population. It would need a substantiated justification, not merely the label “VRA compliance.” It would also need to show that the way it used race was narrowly tailored to that interest. An inflexible target imposed despite conflicting districting considerations makes that showing difficult on the facts given. The record as stated therefore leaves the state with a weak strict-scrutiny defense, while allowing for the possibility that additional evidence could change the assessment.
Now change one fact: remove the racial-percentage instruction. Suppose the records instead show that staff selected neighborhoods solely from past Party P and Party Q vote totals, and the racial change emerged because those totals correlated with race. The district’s effects and city split remain relevant, but the inference of racial predominance becomes much less secure. Evidence of partisan line-drawing is not, by itself, proof that race drove the lines. Conversely, a state cannot defeat direct evidence of race-based selection merely by pointing to a partisan benefit. The two explanations must be tested against the decisions actually made.
What this claim does—and does not—resolve
A racial-gerrymandering claimant need not show that a minority group lost a seat to raise the Equal Protection question about predominant use of race. Likewise, a racial disparity in a map’s outcome does not automatically prove that mapmakers used race predominantly. Keeping the method of drawing the district separate from its electoral effects prevents both mistakes.
This is also why Rucho does not dispose of the hypothetical. A federal court cannot resolve a claim that partisan favoritism, by itself, violates the federal Constitution. It can address a properly supported Equal Protection claim that race predominated in drawing District 3, even when partisan advantage is also alleged. The challenger must prove that distinct racial claim; describing a partisan grievance in racial terms is not enough.
Key takeaways
For an Equal Protection racial-gerrymandering claim, identify the particular district, determine whether race predominated in its design, and, if it did, assess the state’s compelling interest and narrow tailoring. Instructions, data use, and line-drawing choices can help distinguish race from party affiliation when the two are correlated. Neither an unusual shape nor a partisan effect settles that distinction alone.
The next lesson takes up the related but different question of racial vote dilution under Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act, including the revised framework in Louisiana v. Callais (2026).