Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 7

Judicial Review of Gubernatorial Authority and Constitutional Limits

Recommended resources

Hello. In the last lesson, you saw how judges and justices reach California’s courts. Now the focus shifts to what those courts can do when a governor acts. Judicial review is a check on legal authority: a court can block an executive action that exceeds a statute or violates the California or U.S. Constitution. It is not a chance for judges to replace the governor’s policy judgment with one they prefer.

This lesson uses two disputes over California public-health measures to show both sides of that distinction: a court rejecting a challenge to gubernatorial authority, and a court restricting state action on constitutional grounds. Allow about 35–40 minutes, including the short video and readings.


What courts review

Watch the selected portion of CrashCourse’s Judicial Review: Crash Course Government and Politics #21 for an orientation to judicial review. The video concentrates on federal courts; the central idea also applies when California courts review actions by California officials.

Judicial Review: Crash Course Government and Politics #21

CrashCourse’s Judicial Review: Crash Course Government and Politics #21 introduces the courts’ power to assess government action against higher legal authority.

Watch judicial review. Focus on the distinction between reviewing a government action’s legality and reviewing a lower court’s decision on appeal. The examples are mostly federal; for this lesson, keep the California governor’s actions in view.

A governor does not acquire unlimited power by heading the executive branch. For any challenged action, a court can examine two different legal boundaries:

  • Statutory authority: Did a law authorize the governor to do this, under these conditions? An action beyond the authority granted by law is sometimes called ultra vires—beyond the official’s powers.
  • Constitutional limits: Even if a statute authorizes the action, does it violate the California Constitution or the U.S. Constitution?

These are questions about law, not simply about whether a decision was prudent. A judge might regard an emergency rule as unwise yet uphold it because it falls within lawful authority. Conversely, a rule adopted for a worthwhile purpose can be blocked if it crosses a legal boundary. Courts need a case presenting a legal claim; they do not issue a general approval or disapproval of everything a governor does.



A statutory challenge that failed

640 Tenth, LP v. Newsom illustrates why identifying the specific source and limit of authority matters. Business owners challenged California emergency measures, including on the ground that public-health directives had not followed the ordinary rulemaking procedures of the Administrative Procedure Act, or APA. That was a legal argument about required procedure, not merely an objection to the measures’ effects.

Read the indicated passages of the California Court of Appeal opinion. Its legal citations are dense, but the governing question is accessible: whether the emergency law allowed the governor to suspend the APA requirement at issue.

640 Tenth, LP v. Newsom (Cal. Ct. App. 2022)

Read the California Court of Appeal’s discussion of the Emergency Services Act and the APA. It shows a court testing an executive order against statutes rather than accepting or rejecting it on policy grounds.

In “DISCUSSION,” subsection “A. The Governor’s Orders and Public Health Directives Issued Under the Emergency Act Are Not Subject to The APA,” find “1. The Emergency Act and The APA.” On pp. 6–7, read the two statutes: the emergency powers and the ordinary APA process. Then, beginning with the paragraph on the APA’s purposes on p. 7, read the court’s reasoning through its conclusion on the APA objection on p. 9. Pay particular attention to the statutory power to suspend a regulatory statute and to what the governor’s order actually said.

The court did not reason that an emergency makes a governor’s orders immune from review. It examined the legislation conferring emergency powers and the executive order invoking those powers. It concluded that the relevant statute authorized suspension of a regulatory statute under its stated emergency conditions, that the APA fell within that authority, and that the order had suspended its application to the measures at issue. The owners lost this APA-based challenge because the court found statutory authorization, not because courts lacked power to consider it.

That result has a narrow lesson. It does not mean every emergency order is lawful, or that every alleged constitutional violation disappears during an emergency. A different order, statute, or legal claim could require a different analysis. Judicial review can constrain a governor and confirm that the governor has acted within authority the legislature granted.



Constitutional limits remain

A statute can grant broad discretion without eliminating constitutional protections. The California Constitution separates legislative, executive, and judicial power; the U.S. Constitution also protects rights that state officials must respect. A court may therefore have to consider a constitutional objection even where the governor can point to statutory authority.

Tandon v. Newsom provides a concrete federal constitutional example. Read the account below with one distinction in mind: it concerns a California public-health regulation, not a finding that every action personally taken by the governor was unconstitutional.

Tandon v. Newsom (2021) | The First Amendment Encyclopedia

Read the First Amendment Encyclopedia’s account of how the U.S. Supreme Court evaluated a California restriction on gatherings under the Free Exercise Clause.

Start in the opening paragraph at the case account, continuing through the subsection “Court found California COVID law treated secular and religious activities differently.” Focus on the comparison between religious gatherings and permitted secular activities, and on why the state’s justification mattered to the legal result.

California’s rule limited gatherings in private homes, including at-home religious meetings. The Supreme Court focused on the Free Exercise Clause of the U.S. Constitution. Its concern was that California treated comparable secular activities more favorably than religious exercise. Under the constitutional test the Court applied, the state had to justify that difference, including why less restrictive precautions would not address the relevant risk. The Court granted injunctive relief—a judicial order restricting enforcement of the challenged rule.

Notice what makes this judicial review rather than a judicial vote on the best public-health policy. The issue was not whether the justices would have designed the same gathering limits. It was whether the state’s treatment of religious exercise satisfied a constitutional requirement. The ruling restricted an executive-branch measure because of that legal defect; it did not hand the courts general responsibility for writing California’s health rules.

A California constitutional claim would follow the same basic kind of inquiry, though it would invoke a different governing text. For example, if a governor purported to cancel a court judgment simply because the governor disliked it, a court would examine the separation of powers under California’s Constitution. Calling the cancellation efficient or popular would not answer that constitutional objection.



What a judicial check can—and cannot—do

The two cases lead to opposite results but follow a common method. A court identifies the challenged action, the legal rule governing it, and the basis for the claimed violation. It can reject a claim when the action is legally authorized, as with the APA objection discussed in 640 Tenth. It can also restrict enforcement when an action fails a constitutional test, as in Tandon. Depending on the claim and stage of the case, judicial remedies can include an injunction, a declaration about legality, or an order addressing a duty imposed by law.

This differs from the other checks in the course. The legislature can define and revise statutory powers within constitutional limits. Courts decide legal disputes about whether officials have stayed within those powers and constitutional boundaries. Voters can judge a governor’s performance through elections and, under California’s rules, a recall. An election can remove an official without a judicial finding that a particular order was illegal; a court can block an illegal order without removing the governor.

The practical distinction is therefore between “I disagree with this decision” and “this decision violates an identifiable legal limit.” The first is ordinarily a matter for public debate and political accountability. The second is a claim a court can adjudicate—and, if established, use to block government action.



Key takeaways

Judicial review does not place courts above every policy choice the governor makes. It gives them authority to enforce statutory and constitutional boundaries in legal disputes. 640 Tenth shows a court upholding challenged action after finding statutory authority; Tandon shows a court restricting a California measure under the U.S. Constitution. The next module turns to clemency, where the governor has significant authority but must still operate within specified legal limits.