Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 2

Forms of Inner Speech: Expanded, Condensed, Monologic, and Dialogic

Recommended resources

Welcome back. Last lesson separated what a thought is about from how it is experienced: thinking about a conversation does not necessarily mean hearing or saying words inwardly. It also distinguished silently forming an utterance from imagining the sound of someone speaking.

This lesson stays within the territory of inner speech, but treats it as variable rather than as one uniform “voice in the head.” You will learn to recognize two different contrasts: expanded versus condensed inner speech describes how fully language is expressed, while monologic versus dialogic inner speech describes whether it takes the form of one stream or an exchange. Allow about 35–40 minutes, including the video and reading.


Inner speech can be fuller or more compressed

Imagine silently considering a seat near the aisle. One version of the thought might be, “I’ll take the aisle seat because I may need to leave early.” Another might be only “Aisle—easy exit.” Both contain language, but they differ in how much of the utterance is filled in. The second makes sense because the situation supplies what the words leave unsaid.

Researchers call the more fully formed end expanded inner speech. It can retain features of ordinary speech, such as complete phrases or sentences, an imagined rhythm, and sometimes a recognizable voice. Condensed inner speech is more abbreviated: a key word or fragment may carry a meaning that would take several sentences to communicate to someone else. Condensed does not simply mean “spoken faster inside the head.” The utterance itself may omit words and lose some of its speech-like qualities.

Watch Charles Fernyhough’s explanation in The Science of the Voices in your Head, from the Royal Institution. Notice that his examples move between fuller and telegraphic forms; neither form is presented as the one that everyone must use.

The Science of the Voices in your Head – with Charles Fernyhough

In The Science of the Voices in your Head, Charles Fernyhough illustrates expanded and condensed inner speech and explains why people might move between them.

Watch the two forms. Focus on the contrast between complete inward utterances and shortened, context-dependent language. He also introduces conversational inner speech; keep that as a separate feature rather than assuming every expanded utterance is a dialogue.

The comparison with notes written for oneself is useful. “Aisle—easy exit” might be opaque to someone who did not know what seat you were choosing. It is enough for you because the topic is already established. A condensed fragment can also carry associations beyond its dictionary meaning: “aisle” might stand for leaving discreetly, feeling less confined, or remembering a previous experience. This does not require those associations to have been spelled out in additional inward sentences.

The distinction has a difficult edge. If an experience has no identifiable words or linguistic structure at all, should it still count as highly condensed inner speech, or should it count as nonverbal conceptual thought? Researchers disagree. The previous lesson treated wordless thought as a possible description of experience; that remains a useful distinction. The closer an account comes to “I grasped what to do, but there was no phrase or fragment,” the less confidently we can classify it as inner speech merely because it could have been put into words afterward.

The following research article sets out the expanded–condensed contrast. Its account is a proposed model, not a claim that every thought travels through the same fixed stages.

The ConDialInt Model: Condensation, Dialogality, and Intentionality Dimensions of Inner Speech Within a Hierarchical Predictive Control Framework - PMC

Read the article’s account of condensation to see why inner speech can retain many qualities of spoken language or have very few of them.

Under “Introduction” and then “Three Dimensions of Inner Speech,” find the paragraph beginning “These two views can be reconciled if various degrees of unfolding of inner speech are considered.” Read the condensation account to its closing sentence. Focus on the two ends of the proposed range and the possibility of intermediate forms. The authors include an especially broad interpretation of condensed inner speech that approaches wordless thought; keep the boundary question open rather than adopting that interpretation as settled.

One qualification matters throughout: expanded does not guarantee an audible-seeming voice. A person might report a complete, deliberately formed inward sentence while reporting little or no impression of its sound. Conversely, a fleeting fragment might have a vivid sound-like quality. Grammatical fullness and apparent sound often relate, but they are not the same observation.



Inner speech can be one-sided or conversational

Now hold the amount of language roughly constant and change its arrangement. “I’ll take the aisle seat because I may need to leave early” is a monologic example: one continuous inward utterance. “Should I take the center seat?” followed by “No, the aisle will make leaving easier” is dialogic: it has a question-and-response structure.

A dialogue need not involve a second person’s imagined voice. You might produce both turns yourself, with no noticeable change in vocal quality. Alternatively, an exchange might include an imagined response in someone else’s characteristic manner. That latter experience can overlap with the inner hearing and auditory imagery discussed last lesson. The significant feature for recognizing a dialogue is the exchange of turns or perspectives, not the number of distinct-sounding voices.

There is a subtler distinction between a conversation’s form and its content. A single uninterrupted thought can weigh two views—“The center has a better view, although the aisle makes leaving easier”—without being experienced as two speakers taking turns. It is monologic in form while considering alternatives in content. Equally, merely thinking “You can do this” uses the second-person pronoun but does not, by itself, establish an inner conversation. Grammar alone cannot tell you how an utterance was experienced.

Read the article’s treatment of this second dimension. It uses the terms monologal and dialogal for forms of inner language and also distinguishes those forms from having multiple points of view in the content.

The ConDialInt Model: Condensation, Dialogality, and Intentionality Dimensions of Inner Speech Within a Hierarchical Predictive Control Framework - PMC

Continue with the same article to separate the structure of an inward exchange from the presence of another perspective or voice.

Still under “Introduction” and “Three Dimensions of Inner Speech,” move to the paragraph beginning “A second dimension is dialogality.” Read the dialogality account to the paragraph’s closing sentence. Pay particular attention to the contrast between one inward speaker considering different views and an experience structured as an exchange. The authors also discuss imagining another person’s speech; relate that possibility to last lesson’s distinction between inner speaking and inner hearing.

The article offers one way to organize experiences involving other people’s imagined speech. Its terminology does not erase an important ambiguity in a short report such as “I heard what my friend would say.” That could describe a remembered-sounding utterance, a contribution to an imagined conversation, or both. More detail about the experience would be needed to say which.



The two contrasts can cross

Fullness and conversational structure answer different questions. These are illustrative possibilities, not transcripts that everyone should expect to find in their mind:

Form Possible experience while choosing a seat
Expanded, monologic “I’ll choose the aisle seat because I may need to leave early.”
Condensed, monologic “Aisle. Easy exit.”
Expanded, dialogic “Would the center be better?” “Not if I need to leave early; I’ll take the aisle.”
Condensed, dialogic “Center?” “Exit. Aisle.”

A condensed dialogue can be recognizable through a brief question and response, even when neither turn is a complete sentence. An expanded monologue can be quite elaborate without ever becoming a conversation. These combinations are why it is misleading to use internal monologue as though it named all inner speech.

Nor does any cell in the table specify how the utterance sounds. Each could be reported with a strong voice-like quality, a faint one, or none that the person notices. A dialogic version might include another person’s imagined voice, but does not have to. These distinctions describe features of particular experiences; they do not sort people permanently into four types.

Context can also change the form. You might let “Aisle—easy exit” suffice while making a routine choice, then silently formulate a fuller explanation if you need to clarify your decision. Researchers have proposed that demands such as difficulty or stress can affect how expanded inner speech becomes. That is a proposal about possible variation, not a rule that a difficult situation always produces complete inward sentences. It also does not tell us how often either form arises spontaneously—an issue for the next lesson.



Takeaways

Inner speech can range from fuller utterances to highly compressed, context-dependent fragments. Independently, it can take the form of one inward stream or a back-and-forth exchange. Neither fullness nor dialogue requires the experience of an audible-seeming voice. At the most condensed edge, the line between verbal thought and wordless conceptual thought remains contested; an after-the-fact verbal explanation does not settle what was present at the time.

Next, the module turns from what form inner speech can take to another distinction: how often it occurs spontaneously versus whether someone can deliberately produce it or use speech-related processing for a task.