Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 8

From Marx’s Communist Society to the Marxist-Leninist Distinction Between Socialism and Communism

Recommended resources

Marx’s account of a political transition from capitalism raises a related question: what would society be like after capitalist ownership had been replaced? In this lesson, you will examine his answer in two phases, then trace why later Marxist-Leninist usage often calls the first socialism and reserves communism for the second. That distinction is useful when reading political arguments, but it is a later naming convention—not a pair of definitions Marx applied consistently throughout his work.


Why Marx describes two phases

In his 1875 Critique of the Gotha Programme, Marx objected to a proposed workers’ party programme that spoke of “fair distribution” without adequately specifying what society would produce, what it would hold in common, and what could actually be distributed to individuals. His starting point was that a new society would not arrive free of the habits and material limits of the old one. It would emerge from capitalism bearing its “birthmarks.”

Read Marx’s account before attaching later labels to it. His distinction concerns two phases of communist society, not two separately named systems.

Critique of the Gotha Programme-- I

Read Marx's account of the first and higher phases in Part I of Critique of the Gotha Programme. It supplies the primary-source language against which later summaries can be checked.

In Part I, begin with the paragraph opening “What we have to deal with here is a communist society.” Read the first phase through the end of Marx's discussion of unequal individuals. Notice what is deducted before individual producers receive anything, and why he calls an equal measure of labor an unequal right in its effects. Continue immediately with the paragraph beginning “But these defects are inevitable.” Read the higher phase to the closing principle. Identify the changes Marx says must occur before distribution according to need becomes possible.

Marx’s opening description matters as much as his famous closing slogan. He is not first describing capitalism, then suddenly switching to communism. Both phases belong to what he calls communist society. The first has changed who owns the means of production, but it has not overcome every constraint inherited from capitalism.



The lower phase: common production, distribution by labor

In Marx’s lower phase, productive resources are held in common and work is organized socially. Individual producers do not receive private ownership of factories or other productive assets as their reward. They receive a claim on means of consumption—things people can use—based on the labor they have contributed.

That claim comes after deductions from society’s total product. Production must be maintained, common needs met, and provision made for people who cannot work. Marx’s example uses a certificate recording a producer’s contribution of labor; the producer can draw consumption goods corresponding to that contribution after deductions. The certificate illustrates a rule of distribution, not a transfer of ownership over the productive system.

Consider a simplified illustration. Suppose a community records 100 hours of contributed labor and sets aside the equivalent of 20 hours for shared purposes. If the remaining claims are apportioned at the same rate, a person who contributed eight hours receives a claim equivalent to 6.4 hours, while one who contributed four receives a claim equivalent to 3.2. The figures are illustrative; the important point is that individual consumption remains proportional to contributed labor, rather than to each person’s needs.

Marx calls the governing rule an equal right because everyone is assessed by the same standard: labor contributed. He also calls it a form of “bourgeois right.” That phrase does not mean that the capitalist class still owns production in this phase. It means the rule of distribution retains a limitation associated with the old society: people with different capacities and circumstances are judged by one uniform measure.

Two people might contribute equal labor and receive equal claims, yet one may have greater needs—for example, more people dependent on their share. Another person may be able to contribute more labor because of differences in strength, health, or skill. Equal measurement therefore does not guarantee equal circumstances or satisfaction of needs. In Marx’s account, the lower phase is an advance beyond capitalist class ownership, but it is not yet the fullest form of equality he envisages.



The higher phase: why needs become the principle

Marx does not propose simply replacing labor certificates with a new rule by decree. His higher phase depends on deeper changes: the restrictive division of labor and the opposition between mental and physical work have been overcome; work has become more than a way to secure a livelihood; and productive capacity has grown alongside people’s development. Only under such conditions, he argues, can society move beyond measuring each person’s consumption claim against their individual labor.

His formula for that phase is: “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs!” Contribution still matters—people produce together—but an individual’s access to consumption is no longer calculated as the equivalent of their own hours worked. This is why a promise to distribute according to need cannot, by itself, describe Marx’s lower phase.

The contrast is about principles and conditions, not a detailed schedule. Marx does not supply a timetable, an output threshold at which the higher phase begins, or a complete administrative design for either phase. Nor should “according to need” be mistaken for a description of every welfare programme: the phrase sits within an account of common productive ownership and transformed social relations.

In Marx’s account Lower phase of communist society Higher phase of communist society
Productive assets Held in common Held in common
Individual consumption Linked to labor contributed, after common deductions Governed by needs rather than an equivalent-labor claim
Central limitation or condition A uniform labor standard has unequal effects on different people The material and social conditions for moving beyond that standard have developed

This comparison also keeps class separate from differences in individual consumption. Marx says the lower phase recognizes no class differences of the capitalist-owner-versus-worker kind, even though individuals may receive unequal amounts. Unequal consumption alone does not establish that a capitalist ownership class remains.



How “socialism” and “communism” became names for the phases

Marx’s terminology was not the fixed two-word scheme often used today. A historical overview helps locate the later shift without reading it back into every sentence Marx wrote.

Communism | Definition, History, Varieties, & Facts | Britannica

Read Britannica's historical account of how the names socialism and communism came to be associated with Marx's two phases.

In the main article, find the paragraph beginning “Like most writers of the 19th century, Marx tended to use the terms.” Read the terminology shift through the sentence about Lenin's State and Revolution. Focus on the difference between Marx's names for the phases and Lenin's later assignment of the two labels.

Britannica notes that Marx often used socialism and communism interchangeably. In Critique of the Gotha Programme, his explicit contrast is between a first and a higher phase of communist society. In State and Revolution (1917), Lenin identified socialism with Marx’s first phase and communism proper with the higher phase. That pairing became influential in Marxist-Leninist usage.

Keep three claims distinct:

  1. What Marx wrote in the passage: a newly emerged and a higher phase of communist society, with different rules of distribution.
  2. How Lenin named them: socialism for the first phase; communism for the higher one.
  3. What a later government or party claimed to be building: a historical and political claim that requires evidence about its institutions and outcomes, not just its chosen name.

The third claim does not follow automatically from the first two. Marx’s account of distribution does not specify one-party government as a defining feature of the lower phase. Likewise, a party calling itself communist does not thereby claim to have reached Marx’s higher phase. It may be using the name to state an aim or political lineage while describing its present system differently.

One further distinction prevents a common mix-up. Marx’s discussion of transitional political rule—the subject of the preceding outcome—is a question about political power in the change from capitalism. His lower and higher phases describe differences within the society he envisages after capitalism. Later writers connect these ideas in different ways, but calling the lower phase “socialism” does not by itself settle how political authority should be organized or how a historical government actually operated.



Conclusion

Marx’s lower phase combines common ownership with individual consumption claims proportional to labor after shared deductions. He regards that equal standard as limited because people’s capacities and needs differ. His higher phase replaces the labor-based claim with distribution according to need, but only under changed social and productive conditions. “Socialism” for the first phase and “communism” for the higher phase is an influential later convention associated with Lenin, not Marx’s consistent terminology.

This distinction gives you a way to read claims about “socialist” or “communist” systems without letting a label do all the work. The next module examines Lenin’s proposed route to revolution and, later, how communist-party governments’ institutions compared with the ideals they invoked.