The previous lesson explained why Marx thought conflict between owners and wage workers could become a struggle over the organization of society. This lesson follows that struggle into politics. Marx distinguished working-class political rule during a transition from the classless society he hoped would result. Keeping those ideas separate is essential when an argument calls a powerful state “communist” simply because its rulers claim to represent workers.
You will read a short passage by Marx, then use a scholarly account to examine a difficult question: if communism is often described as stateless, how could people still make collective decisions and provide public services?
Why Marx speaks of a political transition
In the previous lessons, class meant a relationship to productive assets and labour, not an income bracket. Capitalist owners control productive assets and hire wage workers. For Marx, ending that class relationship would take more than replacing a government: the arrangements that allow one class to control production would also have to change.
In Critique of the Gotha Programme, Marx calls the period of transformation between capitalist and communist society a political transition period. He says its state can be nothing but the “revolutionary dictatorship of the proletariat.” Here proletariat means the working class, and dictatorship names its political rule during a revolutionary transition. Reading the phrase as though Marx were simply naming the final form of communist society misses his explicit word “between.”
Marx also objects to treating a “free state” as an end in itself. Read his two remarks together: one concerns whether society controls its political institutions; the other names the political period in which capitalist society is being transformed.
Critique of the Gotha Programme-- IV
Read Part IV of Karl Marx’s Critique of the Gotha Programme to see the distinction in his own words. The passage is brief but compressed, so attend to which society each use of “state” refers to.
In Part IV, under “A. ‘The free basis of the state,’” read the state discussion. It starts with Marx’s objection to setting the state “free” and ends with his question about functions that might remain in communist society; read the following sentence as well. Later in Part IV, find the paragraph beginning “Between capitalist and communist society” and read the transition passage through its name for the transitional state. Notice that Marx does not use that name as his answer to the earlier question about communist society.
The contrast is easy to lose because both passages discuss politics. In one, Marx asks what happens while a capitalist society is being transformed. In the other, he asks what political functions remain once society has changed. The first is a claim about transitional rule; the second is a question about the character of a future society.
What “rule of the working class” does—and does not—settle
Marx’s phrase identifies the class whose political power would displace that of the capitalist class. In his account, workers would need political authority to contest existing property relations and establish new ones. This is not the same as saying that class divisions have already disappeared: a political struggle to change them is still under way.
Nor does the phrase, by itself, supply an institutional blueprint. “The working class rules” leaves consequential questions open: Who makes decisions on workers’ behalf? Can representatives be removed? Are speech and association protected? Can those wielding transitional power be held accountable? It would be a mistake both to assume that Marx meant a modern one-person dictatorship and to assume that invoking workers’ rule guarantees democratic practice.
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy helps interpret the historical phrase without collapsing it into either assumption. It also examines Marx’s ideas about political arrangements after the transition.
Karl Marx (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
Read the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry’s discussion of transitional rule and the future polity. It distinguishes the historical sense of Marx’s terminology from the institutional question of how a communist society might govern its shared affairs.
Near the end of the entry’s discussion immediately before “7. Utopianism,” locate the paragraph beginning “Marx’s views on the nature and fate of the state in communist society.” Read the transition distinction through its explanation of why transitional rule is not an institution of communist society. Continue from the paragraph beginning “The character of the state in communist society consists” through the account of form and function, stopping just before “7. Utopianism.” Focus on elections and recall, necessary collective tasks, and the author’s caution about whether “state” is the right word for such a transformed polity.
The entry stresses that dictatorship had a historical connotation of temporary, exceptional rule, rather than necessarily its present-day connotation of totalitarian rule. It describes Marx’s intended transitional government as democratic and concerned with establishing a new order, not preserving the old one. Those points clarify an interpretation of Marx’s intention; they do not establish that any later government calling itself revolutionary met those standards.
A useful test is to separate a claim about whose interests a government says it serves from evidence about how power is exercised. Neither a worker’s party name nor a declaration of workers’ rule answers the second question.
A classless society is not a society with no shared decisions
Marx envisaged a society without a capitalist class controlling production and a wage-working class dependent on it. In that sense, classless means the disappearance of those opposing positions in the organization of production—not the disappearance of differences in people’s abilities, preferences, or opinions.
What, then, does stateless mean? The answer depends partly on what counts as a state. If the word means an institution standing over society and maintaining one class’s domination over another, Marx’s envisioned end would no longer need that kind of state. But people would still have to settle disagreements, coordinate activities, and arrange services. Marx therefore asks which functions analogous to present state functions would remain, rather than claiming that all collective administration would vanish.
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy draws out this distinction between form and function. In form, it points to Marx’s interest in participation, elections, recallable officials, and public offices that do not become the preserve of a separate professional caste. In function, it distinguishes collective tasks—such as coordination and provision of public goods—from organized coercion associated with class-divided societies. The entry also notes uncertainty about how far coercion could really be reduced and whether the resulting polity should still be called a “state.”
Picture a community deciding how to maintain shared infrastructure. It must still choose priorities, allocate work and resources, and resolve disputes. None of those decisions alone proves that a separate class rules it. Conversely, calling an authority a “workers’ government” would not prove that its officials are subordinate to the people affected by their decisions. The distinction turns on social relationships and accountable political power, not the mere presence or absence of administration.
Marx did not leave a detailed design for the future society. His distinction is sharper as a statement of what the transition is for than as a specification of exactly when every institution of the old order would disappear.
Keeping the two claims apart
Marx’s political account can be held in view as two different claims:
| Question | Transitional working-class rule | Envisioned communist society |
|---|---|---|
| What is happening to class relations? | Capitalist class relations are being contested and transformed. | The division between capitalist owners and dependent wage workers has been overcome. |
| Why is political authority at issue? | Workers need political power during the struggle over the old order and its replacement. | Collective decisions remain, but authority should not stand above society as an instrument of class domination. |
| Is this Marx’s final aim? | No. Marx places it between capitalist and communist society. | Yes, as an envisioned classless society—though its precise institutions are not fully specified. |
This distinction describes Marx’s theory, not a finding about any particular government. To assess a historical government, you would need to examine its actual ownership arrangements, class relations, institutions, and distribution of political power. Marx’s stated destination cannot be used as evidence that a government reached it; an institution adopted during a claimed transition cannot, on its own, define the destination either.
Conclusion
Working-class political rule is, for Marx, a transitional claim; classless communism is the envisioned result. His use of “dictatorship of the proletariat” should be read in that historical and temporal context, without assuming either that it means modern autocracy or that a government using the phrase is democratic in practice. Likewise, “stateless” does not mean that a future society would have no collective decisions: the question is whether political authority remains an instrument standing over society and enforcing class domination.
The next lesson adds a further distinction within communist society: Marx’s lower and higher phases. That will help keep the political transition separate from the different ways he imagined a post-capitalist society developing.