Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 9

Why VIX Futures Products Diverge from Spot VIX: Roll Yield and Fees

Recommended resources

Welcome back. The previous lesson explained why a VIX future can trade at a different level from today’s VIX: the future settles on a later date, when a new 30-day volatility window is being measured. This lesson adds one more layer. Many exchange-traded volatility products do not hold one future until settlement. They maintain exposure by repeatedly replacing nearer-dated futures with later-dated ones.

You will follow that rolling exposure through a numerical example, then see why an exchange-traded product can lose value while spot VIX stays unchanged. The same example will also show what an upward- or downward-sloping futures curve does—and does not—tell you about the product’s return.


The product holds a strategy, not today’s VIX

Consider a long, unleveraged, short-term VIX-futures-linked product. Its aim is to gain when its specified futures strategy rises, not to match each percentage change in spot VIX. A common strategy uses the nearest-settling VIX future, called M1, and the next-nearest, M2. Over a settlement cycle, it gradually reduces its M1 exposure and increases its M2 exposure. This keeps its exposure focused on futures with roughly a month remaining to settlement, rather than letting one contract expire and starting over abruptly.

Watch how the changing weights work. The video presents a common short-term strategy; its description should not be taken to mean that every VIX exchange-traded product follows the same benchmark.

Don't buy VXX - VIX Futures Roll Yield CRUSHES it Lower!

“Don't buy VXX — VIX Futures Roll Yield CRUSHES it Lower!” from Volatility Trading Strategies shows how a short-term futures benchmark maintains rolling exposure. Focus on the mechanics rather than the title’s trading advice.

Watch the benchmark for its use of the first two VIX futures. Then watch the changing weights: identify M1 and M2, and notice how exposure shifts toward M2 as M1 approaches settlement.

There are two distinct “one-month” ideas here. Spot VIX measures annualized implied volatility for approximately the next 30 calendar days. A short-term futures strategy maintains exposure to futures roughly a month from their settlement dates. Those futures concern what a VIX-related settlement value will be at a later date. Keeping a futures position about a month from settlement does not turn it into today’s spot VIX.

It is equally important to identify the right curve. The image below plots VIX index values associated with different option-expiration horizons; it is not a plot of tradable VIX futures prices. Its upward slope alone cannot tell you what rolling VIX futures will cost or earn.

Cboe chart of VIX volatility-index values for different expiration months on July 15, 2022. These expiration-specific index values are not M1 and M2 VIX futures quotes, so their slope cannot be used to calculate a futures-linked product’s roll effect.

For the rest of the lesson, “upward-sloping curve” means that M2 costs more than M1 in the VIX futures market. That is contango. When M2 costs less than M1, the futures curve is downward sloping, or in backwardation.



A worked example: spot VIX holds steady

Suppose spot VIX reads 20 at the start and end of an illustrative holding period. Meanwhile, a long futures-linked strategy begins with equal exposure to M1 and M2:

Start End
Spot VIX 20 20
M1 future 22 21.5
M2 future 24 23.5

At the start, the futures curve is in contango: M2 is priced above M1. Over the period, both futures fall by half a volatility point, even though spot VIX does not change. Futures are separately traded contracts, so that combination is possible.

Assume, for a simplified return calculation, that the product has unleveraged exposure split evenly between the two futures. Its approximate gross percentage return is the equally weighted average of their percentage changes:

If the product began at 100, its value would be approximately 97.82 before expenses. For arithmetic only, suppose expenses attributable to this illustrated period reduce its return by another 0.10 percentage points. Its approximate net return would be −2.28%, leaving a value of 97.72. The assumed expense is not a quoted fee for any real product.

The comparison is the point: spot VIX returned 0%; the illustrative product returned about −2.28%. Its exposure was to changing futures prices, and expenses further reduced its return. A real product’s result would also depend on its exact benchmark rules, trading and financing arrangements, and any difference between its market price and indicative value.

Where the roll fits

Now suppose the strategy’s schedule calls for it to change its mix from 50% M1 and 50% M2 to 25% M1 and 75% M2 at the end of the period. It reduces the nearer-dated exposure and adds later-dated exposure so that the position does not become too close to settlement.

Because M2 is more expensive, it is tempting to subtract the entire gap between 23.5 and 21.5 as an immediate loss. Do not do that. The higher quote for M2 is not, by itself, a two-point fee charged when the strategy rebalances. If both futures prices remained unchanged during the rebalance, exchanging exposure between them would not instantly produce a loss equal to their price gap. In the calculation above, the loss came from the futures falling while they were held; the hypothetical expense was an additional deduction.

Why, then, is contango often called a roll headwind? A strategy that continually replaces nearer futures with more expensive later futures remains exposed to contracts whose prices may decline as time passes, if the market’s volatility outlook stays broadly similar. Repeated declines in the contracts held can erode the strategy’s value even while spot VIX is roughly steady. The curve’s slope signals a potential headwind, not a return that can be calculated from one snapshot alone. New market information could instead lift M1, M2, or both and more than offset it.

For another explanation of this distinction, read the “Roll Yield” discussion and the brief section on expenses below. Its worked example uses oil, not VIX: carry over the principle that a futures holding can return something different from a spot measure, but not the suggestion that an expiring VIX future must equal an ordinary spot VIX screen quote. As the previous lesson established, a VIX future finally settles against a Special Opening Quotation.

What is Roll Yield and How Does It Impacts Returns | Money for The Rest of Us

Money for the Rest of Us uses a simple futures example to separate a holding-period futures return from a spot return. Its later discussion identifies expenses and interest on cash as other possible return components.

In the “Roll Yield” section, begin at the return distinction. Continue from the oil example through the paragraph reporting its roll yield; stop before “Become a Better Investor With Our Investing Checklist.” Focus on the fact that the held future loses value while the example’s spot measure does not change. Then find “Other VIX, Commodity, and Bitcoin ETF Return Factors” and read from the return factors through the full sentence about management fees and other expenses. Interest can add to a product’s return; fees and expenses reduce it.

Authors use roll yield in somewhat different ways: some mean the difference between futures and spot returns over a period; others use “roll headwind” more loosely for the effect of maintaining exposure along an upward-sloping curve. For judging an actual product, keep the observable pieces separate: which futures did it hold, how did their prices change while held, how were weights changed, and what expenses applied?



If the futures curve slopes downward

The sign of the potential roll effect can reverse. Imagine spot VIX stays at 24, while M1 starts at 22 and M2 at 20. This is backwardation because the later-settling future is cheaper than the nearer one. Suppose each future rises by half a point over the holding period: M1 to 22.5 and M2 to 20.5.

With the same starting 50/50 exposure, the illustrative gross return is

After the same hypothetical 0.10-percentage-point expense, the product returns approximately 2.29%, while spot VIX again returns 0%. In this example the held futures rose; buying a cheaper M2 at rebalance was not an instant profit.

Backwardation can therefore offer a potential tailwind for a long rolling futures strategy, just as contango can present a headwind. Neither slope guarantees the next price move. A volatility shock, a change in expectations for later months, or other repricing can overwhelm the effect suggested by the curve.



Key takeaways

A VIX-futures-linked product follows the returns of its specified, often rolling futures exposure, not the percentage return of spot VIX. A common short-term strategy gradually shifts exposure from M1 to M2. When the futures curve is upward sloping, maintaining that exposure may create a persistent headwind for a long product; a downward slope may offer a tailwind. The roll itself is not an automatic loss or gain equal to the gap between two futures quotes. Price changes while contracts are held determine futures gains and losses, while fees generally reduce the product’s return.

The next lesson adds daily-reset leveraged and inverse products. Their returns can diverge further because the stated multiple applies to each day’s benchmark return, not automatically to the benchmark’s cumulative return over several days.