Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 61

Unreliable Narrator: Crafting Suspense and Surprise

Recommended resources

An unreliable narrator forces the reader to question what is true and what is a lie, turning the reading experience into an active puzzle.

In our last lesson, we delved into the theory behind the unreliable narrator, exploring the different motivations—from deliberate deception to flawed perception—that can make a character's account of a story untrustworthy. We discussed how this technique transforms the reader into a detective, actively searching for the truth hidden beneath the surface of the narrative.

Today, we move from theory to practice. Your goal is to apply those concepts directly by tackling the learning outcome: to write a short scene from the perspective of an unreliable narrator to create suspense or surprise. This exercise is a vital step toward mastering the kind of misdirection and plot twists you're interested in, as it challenges you to manipulate the reader's perception through carefully chosen words and details.

Part 1: Planning Your Unreliable Scene

Before you begin writing, it's essential to lay the groundwork. A successful unreliable narrator isn't just a character who lies; they are a character whose unreliability is woven into the fabric of the scene. Here is a three-step process to plan your scene.

Step 1: Choose Your Narrator's "Why"

First, decide on the reason for your narrator's unreliability. This choice will define their voice and their version of events. Are they intentionally deceptive, or is their perception genuinely skewed?

This infographic, which we touched upon previously, provides a useful menu of archetypes.

This infographic outlines common archetypes for unreliable narrators, each with a distinct reason for their untrustworthiness.

For this exercise, select one of these types (or the types from our previous lesson, such as The Liar, The Madman, or The Naif). For example:

  • The Liar: A character trying to cover up a mistake or crime.
  • The Deluded: A character who genuinely believes a false reality, perhaps due to obsession or paranoia.
  • The Innocent: A child who misinterprets adult situations.

Your choice of "why" is the foundation of your scene. A liar will choose their words carefully, while a deluded narrator's perspective will feel more emotionally genuine, even if it's factually wrong.

Step 2: Define the Truth vs. the Lie

Once you know why your narrator is unreliable, establish the two competing realities of your scene:

  1. The Objective Truth: What actually happened or is happening.
  2. The Narrator's Version: The skewed account your narrator presents to the reader.

For example:

  • Truth: The narrator was just fired for incompetence.
  • Narrator's Version: "I quit my job today. My boss was devastated, but I couldn't stand to work for such a disorganized company any longer. It was a matter of principle."

This core conflict between reality and perception is what your scene will be built around.

Step 3: Select Your Clues

The reader won't know the objective truth, so you must plant "breadcrumbs" that hint at it. Your goal is to create suspense by making the reader feel that something is off, even if they can't pinpoint what it is.

How to Write an Unreliable Narrator : A Simple Guide for Writers

As a refresher, let's revisit the core techniques for showing unreliability. The article "How to Write an Unreliable Narrator" provides a clear list of methods for planting clues.

Please re-read the sections Step 3 and Step 4. Pay close attention to the specific examples provided, such as contradictions, memory gaps, odd reactions, and physical evidence.

Here are some key types of clues you can plant in your scene:

  • Contradictory Body Language: The narrator says, "I'm perfectly calm," while tapping their foot relentlessly or clenching their fists.
  • Physical Evidence: The narrator describes a tidy room, but mentions stepping over a shattered lamp.
  • Illogical Statements: The narrator's timeline of events doesn't make sense.
  • Reactions of Other Characters: The person the narrator is talking to looks confused, scared, or skeptical of their story. This is a powerful tool, as it uses an external perspective to cast doubt on the narrator's account.

Part 2: The Writing Exercise

Now it's your turn to write. Your task is to apply the planning steps to a short, focused scene.

The Prompt:

Write a short scene (approximately 300-500 words) in the first person. The scene should feature your narrator in conversation with another character. The narrator is trying to explain or justify a recent event, but subtle clues should reveal to the reader that their version of the story is not the truth. The scene should aim to create either suspense or a surprising reveal at the end.

A Checklist for Your Scene:

  1. Establish a clear voice. Based on your chosen narrator type, decide how they speak. Is their tone defensive, overly cheerful, detached, or grandiose? The voice itself can be a major clue.
  2. State the "lie" clearly. The narrator should present their version of events.
  3. Weave in at least two clues. Use body language, physical evidence, or another character's reaction to contradict the narrator's story.
  4. End with impact. Conclude the scene in a way that solidifies the reader's suspicion or provides a small, shocking reveal that re-frames what they just read.

Remember, the goal isn't to confuse the reader, but to engage them in a puzzle. You are creating dramatic irony: the reader suspects something that other characters (and perhaps the narrator themself) do not fully grasp.

How to make your writing suspenseful - Victoria Smith

The TED-Ed video "How to make your writing suspenseful" explains how controlling information creates tension. The principles here are directly applicable to writing an unreliable narrator.

Watch the section on limiting the point of view. This is exactly what a first-person unreliable narrator does—it locks the reader into a single, flawed perspective. Then, watch the explanation of dramatic irony. This is the effect you are trying to create: letting the audience know more (or suspect more) than the characters.


Part 3: Example Deconstruction

To help you visualize the final product, here is a short example scene followed by a breakdown of the techniques used.

Scene Example:

"It's fine, really," I said, arranging the wilting roses in the vase on the kitchen counter. "We had a disagreement, that's all. A mature conversation." My hand trembled slightly as I snipped a thorny stem, and I pressed my lips into a firm line. I hate it when my hands shake. It’s a sign of low blood sugar, nothing more.

Sarah leaned against the doorframe, her arms crossed tight. She wasn't looking at the roses. Her eyes were fixed on the new, spiderweb-thin crack in the drywall next to the refrigerator. "A mature conversation?" she repeated, her voice flat.

"Yes. I explained my point of view, and he explained his." I forced a bright smile. "We agreed to disagree. He just went out for some air. He does that." I nudged a framed photo on the counter, turning it face down. It was a picture of Mark and me, smiling on a beach. The glass was cracked. "Silly thing fell over earlier. So clumsy."

"His car is gone, Alex," Sarah said softly. "And his coat. And that awful leather bag he takes everywhere."

I finally managed to get the roses to stand up straight. They looked pathetic, drooping like they’d already given up. "He'll be back," I said, my voice barely a whisper. "He just needed some air."


Deconstruction:

  • Narrator Type: The Deluded / The Liar. Alex is trying to convince both Sarah and himself that a major fight or breakup was just a minor disagreement.
  • The "Truth" vs. The "Lie":
    • Lie: "We had a mature conversation... He just went out for some air."
    • Truth: Mark has packed a bag and left Alex after a violent argument.
  • The Clues:
    1. Contradictory Body Language: Alex claims it was a "mature conversation," but his "hand trembled" and he forces a smile. He rationalizes the shaking as low blood sugar, a classic move of an unreliable narrator explaining away evidence.
    2. Physical Evidence: The scene is littered with clues: the "crack in the drywall," the "cracked" glass of the "face down" photo, and the "wilting roses" (symbolism for a dying relationship). Alex provides weak, dismissive excuses for each.
    3. The Other Character's Reaction: Sarah acts as the voice of reality. Her "flat" tone, crossed arms, and focus on the evidence (the crack, the missing car and bag) directly challenge Alex's narrative. Her final, soft-spoken lines deliver the devastating facts that Alex is ignoring.
  • The Ending: The scene ends not with a confession, but with Alex clinging to his delusion. His final, whispered line, "He just needed some air," is heartbreakingly pathetic and confirms for the reader that he is completely unreliable. The suspense comes from wondering what will happen when he is forced to face the truth.

Conclusion

Writing from an unreliable narrator's perspective is a powerful exercise in subtext and control. It's about what you don't say as much as what you do. By carefully choosing your narrator's motivation, defining the gap between their story and the truth, and planting subtle clues, you can create scenes that are deeply suspenseful and psychologically rich.

Key Takeaways:

  • Plan your scene by first deciding why your narrator is unreliable.
  • Clearly define the objective truth versus the narrator's skewed version.
  • "Show, don't tell" the unreliability by using clues like contradictory body language, physical evidence, and the reactions of other characters.
  • Use the unreliable perspective to build suspense and surprise, making the reader an active participant in uncovering the truth.

As you become comfortable manipulating reader perception on this small scale, you'll be better equipped to construct the larger misdirections and plot twists that drive compelling mysteries.

In our next lesson, we will move on to a different kind of scene-crafting. We'll explore how to write an effective action sequence focusing on pacing, clarity of movement, and cause-and-effect. While this lesson focused on internal tension, the next will be all about external, physical conflict.