Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 55

Rapid Prototyping: Design, Print, Evaluate, Iterate

Recommended resources

Hello! Welcome to the final lesson in our "First Practical Projects" module.

In the previous lesson, you did the important work of measuring a real-world object and translating it into a V1 (version one) digital model in Fusion 360. You've successfully bridged the gap from physical to digital. Now, it's time to complete the cycle.

Today's Goal: Your learning outcome is to print the replacement part, evaluate its fit, and iterate on the design for improvement.

This lesson is all about the iterative nature of design and prototyping. It's rare to get a perfect fit on the first try. The real skill lies in observing what’s wrong with a prototype and knowing how to fix it. This process of printing, testing, and refining is the core of functional 3D printing and will be essential for your projects, from gaming accessories to your custom PC desk.

1. The First Prototype: Printing and Evaluating

Your first step is to bring your V1 model into the physical world.

Printing Your V1 Model

  1. In Fusion 360, select the body of your part in the Browser tree.
  2. Go to File > 3D Print.
  3. Ensure the format is set to 3MF (it's generally preferred over STL as it can contain more data, like units and colors).
  4. Make sure "Send to 3D Print Utility" is checked and select Bambu Studio. Click OK.
  5. In Bambu Studio, use "prototype quality" settings to save time and material. This typically means:
    • A standard or slightly larger layer height (e.g., 0.2mm or 0.24mm).
    • Reduced wall loops (e.g., 2 walls).
    • Low infill percentage (e.g., 10-15%).
  6. Slice the model and send it to your printer.

Evaluating the Fit
Once your part is printed, it's time for the moment of truth. Don't be discouraged if it doesn't fit perfectly; that's the point of this exercise.

  1. Clean the part: Remove any support material or brim if you used them.
  2. Test the fit: Try to assemble it with its mating part.
  3. Observe and measure: Use your calipers and your eyes to diagnose the issues.
Measuring a 3D Printed Part with Calipers Against an Engineering Drawing
Just as you measured the original object, use your calipers to measure your printed part. Comparing the intended dimensions from your CAD model to the actual printed dimensions is key to understanding your printer's behavior.

Ask yourself these questions:

  • Is it too tight or too loose? If so, by how much? Use your calipers to measure the gap or the amount of interference.
  • Do features line up? Are screw holes in the right place? Do tabs engage with their slots?
  • Is the print quality affecting the fit? Look for issues like a squashed first layer ("elephant's foot") or warping that prevent the part from sitting flat or fitting correctly.

2. Why Doesn't It Fit? Understanding Tolerance

The discrepancy between your digital model and your physical print is due to manufacturing tolerances. While you may be familiar with the tight tolerances of CNC machining from your engineering background, Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF) 3D printing is a much less precise process. Deviations are caused by many factors, including material shrinkage, nozzle drag, and slight inconsistencies in filament extrusion.

The following video provides an excellent conceptual overview of tolerance, the different types of "fits" in mechanical design, and why simply modeling two parts to the exact same dimension will cause them to interfere.

Beginner's Guide to Fit and Tolerance in Fusion 360 - Get the Perfect Fit from Your 3D Printer / CNC

This video from Practical Alchemy, 'Beginner's Guide to Fit and Tolerance in Fusion 360', introduces the core concepts you need to understand to solve fitment issues.

Please watch from the beginning to 8:25. The video explains: Part Tolerance: Why a printed part's dimensions deviate from the CAD model. Tolerance Stacking: How small deviations in two mating parts add up. The Three Fit Types: A clear explanation of Interference Fit (press-fit), Clearance Fit (sliding/rotating parts), and Transition Fit (a snug, non-interfering fit).


3. The Iteration Loop: Test, Revise, Repeat

Now that you've evaluated your V1 print, it's time to go back to Fusion 360 and create V2. This iterative loop is central to design.

Iterative 3D Print Design Process
An iterative process involves creating multiple versions of a part. Each version incorporates learnings from the previous one, getting you closer to a perfect result.

The video below is a great practical demonstration of a designer going through this exact process.

Designing Your First Functional 3D Printed Parts | Basic Fusion 360 3D Printing

Let's revisit the 'Designing Your First Functional 3D Printed Parts' video by JJ Shankles. Pay close attention to how he diagnoses the problems with his first prints and translates those observations into specific changes in his Fusion 360 model.

Watch these key moments of iteration: Air Vent Clip V1 -> V2 (08:51 - 11:49): He identifies that the clip rocks and slides. He goes back to the original sketch, edits dimensions to make it longer, and adds a feature to make it sit flat. Dishwasher Clip V1 -> V2 (14:56 - 15:55): The first prototype's hooks are too short. He simply goes back into the sketch, increases the length of the hooks, and prints a second prototype.

How Much to Adjust?

The key question is, "If my part is 0.5mm too tight, how much do I change my model?"

  • For External/Internal Fits: A good rule of thumb is to apply half the total required change to each side. If a peg is 0.5mm too thick to fit in a hole, you can make the peg 0.25mm smaller on all sides (using Press Pull with a -0.25mm offset) or make the hole 0.25mm larger on all sides (using the Offset tool in the sketch with a 0.25mm offset).
  • General Guidelines: If you don't have a precise measurement, you can start with common clearance values.

How to 3D Print Pieces for Assembly

This article, 'How to 3D Print Pieces for Assembly', provides some useful starting points for tolerances.

Read 'Step 3: Choosing the Right Tolerances'. It provides general clearance values for different types of fits, such as 0.1-0.2mm for a press-fit and 0.3-0.5mm for a loose-fit. These are great starting points for your adjustments.

A Hands-On Approach to Finding Your Printer's Tolerances

Since you prefer learning by designing and printing test pieces, the best way to determine the right clearances is to create your own tolerance test, often called a "fit block." This will tell you exactly what clearance values produce a press-fit, transition-fit, and clearance-fit on your specific printer with your chosen material.

The video from Practical Alchemy that you watched earlier continues to show exactly how to design and use one of these.

Beginner's Guide to Fit and Tolerance in Fusion 360 - Get the Perfect Fit from Your 3D Printer / CNC

This part of the 'Beginner's Guide to Fit and Tolerance' video shows how to create and use a simple test block to empirically find the perfect fit values for your machine. This is a powerful technique for any functional design.

Watch from 8:25 to 13:30. This section covers: Designing a 'Fit Block' (8:25 - 10:00): See how a simple block with holes of varying offsets is created. Using the Fit Block (10:00 - 13:30): Observe the process of testing a single peg in each hole to identify which offset value corresponds to the desired fit. Creating and printing a similar test piece for yourself is a highly recommended activity.


4. Your Turn: Iterate on Your Replacement Part

Armed with this knowledge, it's time to fix your V1 model.

  1. Identify the Problem: Based on your evaluation, what needs to change? (e.g., "The battery cover is 0.4mm too wide to slide into its slot.")
  2. Plan the Solution: How will you fix it in Fusion 360? (e.g., "I will use Press Pull on the two side faces with an offset of -0.2mm each.")
  3. Modify Your Design: Open your V1 file. Use the timeline to go back and edit the original sketch or feature. Avoid adding new features on top of old ones if you can—editing the history is a more robust workflow.
  4. Save as V2: Use File > Save As to save your modified design as "part_name_V2". This preserves your design history.
  5. Print and Test Again: Print your V2 and see if the changes had the desired effect. You may need a V3 or even a V4, and that is perfectly normal.

Conclusion

Congratulations on completing the full design cycle! You have now experienced the most important workflow in functional 3D printing: taking a need, creating a digital solution, and iteratively refining a physical prototype until it works perfectly.

Key Takeaways:

  • Iteration is a fundamental, expected part of the design process. The goal of a first print is to gather information for the next version.
  • Evaluating a print involves testing its physical fit and function, then using calipers to quantify any errors.
  • Design adjustments are made back in CAD by editing the parametric history—often by changing a single dimension in a sketch.
  • Understanding your specific printer's tolerances, ideally through a hands-on test like a "fit block," is the key to designing parts that fit right the first time.

Next Lesson Preview:
You've now successfully completed your first practical projects! You're ready to move on to more complex modeling challenges. In the next module, "Advanced Modeling & Design Refinement," we'll start by learning how to create and use construction planes and axes. This will allow you to build geometry that isn't tied to the default origin planes, opening up a new world of design possibilities.