Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 12

Federal Source Restrictions on Super PAC Fundraising

Recommended resources

Hello. In the previous lesson, you saw why a super PAC’s ad must remain independent of a candidate’s campaign: coordinated spending is generally treated as an in-kind contribution. Independence, however, is not the only condition on a super PAC. This lesson addresses a separate issue: who may supply its money.

You will distinguish an unlimited amount from an unrestricted source, then apply federal rules involving foreign nationals, federal contractors, national banks, and federally chartered corporations. Allow about 35–40 minutes to read and work through the examples.


“Unlimited” describes an amount, not every donor

A super PAC—formally, an independent-expenditure-only political committee—may generally accept contributions of unlimited size from individuals, ordinary corporations, labor organizations, and other political committees. It uses those funds for independent spending, not contributions to candidates. The absence of an amount limit does not mean that every person or entity is an eligible donor.

The Federal Election Commission (FEC) states the permitted sources and the principal prohibited sources together. Read its short rule before examining the exceptions.

FEC | PAC | Contributions to Super PACs and Hybrid PACs

Read this FEC guidance for its distinction between contributions of unlimited size and contributions from prohibited sources.

Under “Contributions to Super PACs and Hybrid PACs,” read the paragraph beginning “Political committees that make only independent expenditures” through the sentence ending “national banks or federally chartered corporations.” The source rule also mentions a hybrid PAC’s non-contribution account; focus here on its application to super PACs.

The distinction is easiest to keep straight by separating three rules that answer different questions:

  • An amount rule governs how much an eligible donor may give. A super PAC generally has no federal amount limit for contributions from eligible sources.
  • A source rule governs whether that donor may give at all. The FEC lists foreign nationals, federal contractors, national banks, and federally chartered corporations as prohibited sources.
  • An independence rule governs what the super PAC does with its funds. As the previous lesson showed, a coordinated ad can become an in-kind contribution even if the super PAC paid the vendor directly.

Passing one test does not waive the others. A contribution from a prohibited source is not cured because it is small, and an eligible donation does not authorize coordinated spending.



Foreign nationals: funding and decision-making

For federal election activity, the foreign-national prohibition reaches more than a check made out directly to a super PAC. The FEC describes restrictions on foreign nationals making election-related contributions and expenditures and participating in decisions about another person’s election-related activity. That second part matters when, for example, an organization has people of different citizenship or immigration statuses involved in its management.

Read the FEC’s explanation of who counts as a foreign national, followed by its discussion of permanent residents and election-related decisions.

Foreign nationals | FEC

The FEC’s “Foreign nationals” guidance explains the scope of the prohibition and an important exception. Read these portions to distinguish an ineligible donor from a person who may contribute, and to see why the identity of the decision-maker matters.

In the opening explanation under “Foreign nationals,” begin with “The Act and Commission regulations include a broad prohibition” and continue through the list in “Definition,” ending with the final bullet about an entity whose principal place of business is in a foreign country. Follow the prohibition and definition, paying particular attention to contributions and independent expenditures. Then read “Individuals: The ‘green card’ exception,” beginning “The Act does not prohibit individuals with permanent resident status,” and the immediately following subsection, “Participation by foreign nationals in decisions involving election-related activities,” through its paragraph ending “the nonfederal accounts of any of these committees.” In these two subsections, focus on the difference between being permitted to contribute and being barred from directing election-related decisions.

The central distinction is legal status, not birthplace or where an account is held. A person who is a U.S. citizen—including a dual citizen—is not barred as a foreign national. Nor is a lawful permanent resident: the FEC explains that permanent residents may make election-related contributions under this rule. A foreign citizen who is neither a U.S. citizen nor a lawful permanent resident cannot make a contribution to a super PAC merely by using funds held in a U.S. bank account. Foreign corporations are also among the foreign nationals described in the FEC guidance.

Decision-making calls for a separate check. A foreign national cannot direct, control, or participate in decisions about a person’s election-related contributions or expenditures, or the management of a political committee. Thus, identifying a domestic organization as the named donor does not settle every relevant fact about how its political spending decision was made. At the same time, a company’s foreign ownership alone is not a complete analysis of a proposed transaction; the funding and decision-making facts require attention.



Federal contractors and federally chartered institutions

The other entries on the FEC’s prohibited-source list are easy to overlook because some are otherwise familiar domestic donors.

A federal contractor is a person or entity with a qualifying contracting relationship with the federal government. The prohibition is relevant during the applicable contracting period, which can include the period of negotiating a federal contract as well as its performance. For a proposed contribution, the useful fact is whether the donor is a covered contractor—not simply whether the donor works somewhere that sells goods or services to the government. An employee’s personal contribution is not automatically prohibited solely because the employer holds a federal contract. The employer cannot evade a restriction by supplying money through someone else.

National banks and federally chartered corporations are also prohibited sources for super PAC contributions under the FEC guidance. Here, charter refers to the institution’s legal authorization to exist, not the bank that processes a payment. A donor’s use of a national bank account does not transform that donor into a national bank. Likewise, “national bank” does not mean every business with “bank” in its name, and “federally chartered corporation” does not mean every corporation operating in the United States.

These categories can overlap. An otherwise eligible, state-incorporated corporation may be unable to contribute while it is a covered federal contractor. Calling it a corporation that can generally fund a super PAC would miss the more specific source restriction.



Reading a proposed super PAC contribution

Consider a super PAC preparing an independent federal candidate ad. Its independence is stipulated: no qualifying coordination with the campaign occurred. That resolves the ad issue from the last lesson, but the committee still needs to evaluate its incoming funds.

First, a state-incorporated company offers to give from its own funds. Ordinary corporate treasury money is not categorically barred from super PAC fundraising. If the company is not a covered federal contractor, national bank, federally chartered corporation, or otherwise prohibited source, the federal rule discussed here does not impose an amount cap on its contribution. Calling the proposed gift “corporate” is therefore not enough to reject it.

Next, a foreign citizen who is not a lawful permanent resident offers a much smaller gift. The smaller amount changes nothing: the source is prohibited. By contrast, a lawful permanent resident offering personal funds is not a foreign national under this rule. Eligibility must not be inferred simply from an accent, a birthplace, or an overseas connection.

Now suppose a domestic supplier offers a large gift while negotiating a covered federal contract. Its domestic incorporation does not answer the contractor issue; its contracting status may make it a prohibited source. Finally, suppose a national bank offers to fund the ad. Paying for independent advocacy rather than contributing to the candidate does not remove the bank from the FEC’s prohibited-source list.

A reliable source check therefore proceeds in this order:

  1. Identify the actual donor and, where relevant, who supplies and controls the funds.
  2. Check prohibited-source status, including foreign-national status and involvement in election decisions, federal-contractor status, and whether an institutional donor is a national bank or federally chartered corporation.
  3. Only then consider amount and use. An eligible super PAC contribution can be unlimited in amount, but the committee’s spending must remain independent to avoid the contribution consequences discussed previously.


Takeaway

The precise rule is not “anyone can give unlimited money to a super PAC.” It is that a super PAC can generally accept unlimited contributions from eligible sources for independent spending. Foreign nationals, federal contractors, national banks, and federally chartered corporations remain important federal exclusions; the foreign-national rules also reach participation in election-related decisions.

The next lesson turns to what the public can learn about election money through disclosure reports and on-ad disclaimers—a different set of rules from those governing whether a contribution may be accepted in the first place.