Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 11

Determining In-Kind Contributions Under Federal Coordinated-Communication Rules

Recommended resources

Welcome. The previous lesson traced how a super PAC can pay for an ad without contributing to a candidate. That distinction depends on independence: paying the ad vendor instead of the campaign does not, by itself, make the spending independent.

This lesson gives you a way to assess a federal-election ad. You will identify who paid for it, what it says, and how the payer and campaign interacted. When all three parts of the federal coordinated-communication test are met, the payment is generally treated as an in-kind contribution rather than an independent expenditure. Allow about 40–45 minutes for the lesson and readings.


Why an ad can become a contribution

Imagine a political committee pays a television station to run “Vote for Candidate A.” No money enters Candidate A’s campaign account. If the campaign asked the committee to run that ad, however, the committee has supplied something valuable to the campaign: advertising it would otherwise have had to purchase. An in-kind contribution is a contribution of goods or services rather than a check.

The Federal Election Commission (FEC) applies a three-prong test to determine whether a communication paid for by someone else is coordinated with a federal candidate or party. All three prongs must be satisfied:

  1. Payment: Someone other than the candidate, the candidate’s authorized committee, or the party committee with which the ad is coordinated pays for it, in whole or in part.
  2. Content: The communication meets at least one specified content standard. A public ad expressly urging people to vote for an identified federal candidate is a straightforward example.
  3. Conduct: The payer’s interaction with the candidate, campaign, or party meets at least one specified conduct standard—for example, the campaign requests the ad or helps make material decisions about it.

The content prong concerns the message; the conduct prong concerns the relationship behind its production or distribution. An ad can enthusiastically support a candidate yet remain independent if the relevant conduct prong is not met.

Read the FEC’s candidate-facing guide for the basic test and its most useful conduct examples. Its content section lists other qualifying messages too; you need not memorize every category to analyze an express “vote for” ad.

FEC | Candidate | Coordinated communications

The Federal Election Commission’s “Coordinated communications” guide explains the test in terms suitable for analyzing an ad, rather than a court opinion.

Start at “Coordinated communications.” Read from the overview through “Determining coordination.” Then read the “Payment prong” and “Content prong” subsections, beginning with who pays. In “Conduct prong,” read “1) Request or suggestion,” “2) Material involvement,” and “3) Substantial discussion,” starting at request or suggestion and continuing through the substantial-discussion explanation. Focus on how any one qualifying form of interaction can meet the conduct prong.

A formal agreement is not required. A campaign’s request can meet the conduct standard; so can the campaign’s material involvement in choosing an ad’s audience or timing. A substantial discussion requires more than ordinary conversation: campaign plans or needs must be conveyed in a way that is material to making or distributing the communication.



Apply the test to a candidate ad

The FEC’s illustrated example puts two visible facts in front of you: a PAC paid for a “Vote for” ad, and its authorization line names the candidate’s campaign committee. The picture is useful for spotting what to investigate, but an ad’s printed words alone do not establish every underlying interaction.

FEC illustration of a PAC-paid “Vote for Beth Clarkhill” ad with an authorization line naming the candidate’s campaign committee. It provides visible clues about payment and content; the conduct analysis depends on what the payer and campaign actually did.

Consider a version with the relevant facts established. A PAC pays to produce and place this ad. Before it does so, the candidate’s campaign asks the PAC to run it. The payment prong is met because the PAC, not the campaign, pays. The content prong is met because “Vote for Beth Clarkhill” expressly advocates election. The campaign’s request meets the conduct prong. The PAC’s payment is therefore a coordinated communication, generally treated as an in-kind contribution. Paying the station directly does not preserve its independence.

Now change only the interaction: a super PAC chooses the message, audience, and timing itself, without a qualifying request or other qualifying conduct involving the campaign. Payment and content still meet their prongs, but the stipulated facts do not meet the conduct prong. Under this test, the ad is not a coordinated communication. That is the critical distinction behind the super PAC spending route discussed previously.

Read the governing regulation to see the legal consequence and the precise request, involvement, and discussion standards. The selected passages are enough for this example; the regulation also contains more detailed content and conduct categories.

eCFR :: 11 CFR 109.21 -- What is a “coordinated communication”?

This FEC-hosted text of the federal regulation supplies the rule behind the guide and shows why coordination changes the legal classification of an ad payment.

In § 109.21(a), “Definition,” read from the three requirements. In § 109.21(b), “Treatment as an in-kind contribution and expenditure; Reporting,” read the “General rule,” beginning the consequence; continue to the end of that paragraph. In § 109.21(c), “Content standards,” locate (c)(3), the public-communication standard for express advocacy. In § 109.21(d), “Conduct standards,” read (d)(1) “Request or suggestion,” (d)(2) “Material involvement,” and (d)(3) “Substantial discussion,” from the conduct rules. Notice that the timing and audience of an ad can matter, not just its script.

Treating spending as a contribution has practical consequences. Contribution limits, source restrictions, and reporting rules can apply even though the payer never wrote a check to the campaign. That does not mean every coordinated payment is lawful: a payment too large for a permitted contributor, or one from a prohibited source, cannot be justified by calling it an ad purchase. The regulation has special reporting and recipient-treatment rules when coordination rests only on its common-vendor or former-employee standards; the payer’s contribution obligations can still matter.



What the visible clues cannot prove

Real advertisements rarely arrive with a complete account of how they were made. Shared personnel or a shared vendor is not, by itself, proof of coordination. The common-vendor standard has additional requirements concerning services and material information. Conversely, a “not authorized by any candidate” disclaimer is not a substitute for examining the actual conduct.

Public information matters as well. If an outside group builds an ad using only campaign positions available to everyone, that fact does not, by itself, show a substantial private discussion or material involvement. The regulations provide safeguards for certain uses of publicly available information and for an appropriately implemented firewall separating people working for the campaign from those working for an outside spender. Those safeguards have conditions; they are not a blanket declaration that any ad made from public material is independent.

Use the final part of the FEC guide to put boundaries around the conduct test.

FEC | Candidate | Coordinated communications

Return to the FEC guide for its explanation of circumstances that do not establish the conduct prong.

Under “Safe harbor provisions to the conduct prong,” read “Safe harbor for publicly available information,” from public information. Then read “Safe harbor for use of a firewall,” starting the firewall conditions. Focus on the conditions each safeguard addresses rather than assuming that a common vendor automatically establishes coordination.

When a news account says an outside group “worked with” a campaign, the useful legal follow-up is to identify the particular conduct alleged. A campaign request to run an ad is different from a vendor’s mere employment history; a material discussion of private campaign plans is different from reading a publicly posted policy position.



Takeaway

For a federal candidate ad, keep the test in order: who paid, whether the message meets a content standard, and whether the payer’s interaction with the campaign meets a conduct standard. All three are needed for a coordinated communication under this rule. When they are met, the outside payment is generally an in-kind contribution, not the independent spending that permits a super PAC to operate without candidate-contribution limits.

The next lesson turns from an ad’s independence to its funding source: even a genuinely independent super PAC cannot accept money from every possible donor.