Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 9

From Anti-Catholic Effigies to Modern Bonfire Night

Recommended resources

Welcome back. In the previous lesson, you saw how James I described the plot’s failure as a divine deliverance and how the 1606 Thanksgiving Act made its commemoration an annual observance. This lesson follows what people did on 5 November after that: attending services, lighting bonfires, burning effigies, collecting money for a “Guy,” and watching fireworks.

The important question is not simply when each custom appeared. It is who or what the celebration targeted, and how much of its original religious message remained. Allow about 35–40 minutes to read, watch, and compare the dated examples.


From thanksgiving to anti-Catholic spectacle

The 1606 Act established annual church services and sermons. Bells, bonfires, and even fireworks also appeared in early celebrations, but the Act did not prescribe the later custom of burning a Guy Fawkes figure. The distinction matters: an official reason for observing the date could remain in place while popular ways of observing it developed.

UK Parliament’s Commemoration of the Gunpowder Plot traces those later customs. You saw its account of the Act last lesson; this time, concentrate on the changing effigies and the nineteenth-century street traditions.

Commemoration of the Gunpowder Plot - UK Parliament

Read UK Parliament’s account to distinguish the annual observance from the customs that grew around it.

On the “Commemoration of the Gunpowder Plot” page, begin with the paragraph opening “The custom of burning effigies of the Pope.” Read the changing effigies, noting the cautious words “seems” and “perhaps.” Then read the paragraph opening “This chant was one of many” through its final reference to playgrounds, parks, and streets: the collecting custom.

Parliament places the apparent beginnings of Pope or devil effigies in the reign of Charles I (1625–49), with greater popularity during the 1678–81 crisis over the succession of James II. Those are later developments, not evidence that a figure of Fawkes had been burned every November since 1605. An effigy of the Pope made the perceived threat of Catholicism visible. It also showed how a celebration of escape from particular conspirators could become an occasion for hostility toward a much wider religious community—the distinction established in the previous lesson.

English Heritage supplies a more specific dated example: crowds parading and burning a Pope effigy in 1673. Read its short account alongside Parliament’s rather than treating either date as a proven “first ever” burning. Customs can emerge unevenly, and a dated description of crowds is different from a claim about the earliest instance anywhere.

5 things you might not know: The Real Story of Bonfire Night | English Heritage

Read English Heritage’s account for its 1673 example, its dating of the familiar Guy Fawkes effigy, and its description of present-day celebrations.

In item 5, “The Guy on the bonfire was originally the Pope,” read the whole item, stopping before “THE LONG READ.” Focus on the difference between the figure displayed in 1673 and the figure the account says became familiar during the 1800s.

The two accounts fit together without providing a neat handover date. Parliament describes Pope and devil effigies as a custom developing across the seventeenth century; English Heritage singles out a Pope-effigy procession in 1673. Both place the familiar burning Guy later. Parliament tentatively links Guy Fawkes’s usual replacement of the Pope to the removal of restrictions on Catholic worship. That is a possible explanation for a change in emphasis, not proof that every locality changed its effigy at the same moment or for the same reason.



A bonfire in 1776—and a changing “Guy”

A dated image helps separate what we can observe from what we might assume. This engraving depicts a November celebration at Windsor Castle in 1776.

An engraving dated 1776 depicts a nighttime crowd, bonfire, and fireworks at Windsor Castle. It shows that these public festivities were established by then, but does not establish which effigies, if any, were burned there.

The gathering looks recognizably connected to Bonfire Night: people assemble around a fire, with fireworks overhead. Yet the engraving does not license a conclusion that all participants shared one motive, or that a Pope or Fawkes effigy was the centre of this particular event. A picture can show the form of a celebration without settling its meaning for every person present.

By the later eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, accounts increasingly feature a Guy: a figure carried through the streets, associated with children asking for “a penny for the Guy,” and eventually the familiar figure burned on bonfires. ClickView’s short video makes the transition from that street custom to present-day gatherings easy to see. Its reference to youths parading figures in the later eighteenth century need not conflict with English Heritage’s dating of the familiar bonfire effigy to the 1800s: carrying a figure and its becoming the usual figure burned are different claims.

Bonfire Night, Guy Fawkes and the Failed Gunpowder Plot | History | ClickView

Watch ClickView’s “Bonfire Night, Guy Fawkes and the Failed Gunpowder Plot” for the shift from public thanksgiving toward Guy-centred customs and contemporary community celebrations.

In the section after its account of the 1606 observance, watch penny for Guy for the paraded figures and changing name of the day. Continue with today's gathering for bonfires, fireworks, and food. Notice which practices persist even as their religious and political emphasis changes.

Calling the figure “the Guy” does not mean that everyone had come to admire the historical Fawkes. In this setting, his name could identify the condemned plotter represented by the effigy. At the same time, “penny for the Guy” made that figure part of a children’s collecting custom, rather than only a symbol in a sermon about Protestant deliverance. A custom can retain a historical name while changing what participants mainly do and think about.



What modern Bonfire Night retains—and what it changes

A modern bonfire can still include a Guy Fawkes effigy, as this photograph shows.

A Guy Fawkes effigy burns amid wooden pallets while spectators watch. The photograph shows the continuing effigy-and-bonfire custom; it does not, by itself, reveal the spectators’ beliefs about the plot.

Compare it with the 1776 engraving. Both depict people gathered at a large fire, although only the engraving shows fireworks. The modern photograph makes the Fawkes figure unmistakably central. Neither image alone tells us whether its spectators understand the day as thanksgiving, condemnation of treason, an evening of entertainment, or some combination.

English Heritage characterizes present-day Bonfire Night as largely separated from its anti-Catholic origins, with fireworks, bonfires, and revelry at the centre. ClickView likewise emphasizes community gatherings and food. These accounts describe a broad change in emphasis, not a claim that every celebration is identical or that the older hostility never mattered. Nor are fireworks a purely modern addition: they were present in some early celebrations. What changed was their prominence within an occasion whose original official purpose had been religious thanksgiving.

The dated examples therefore support a comparison, rather than a single story of one custom replacing another overnight:

Date or period What the example establishes
1606 Annual services and sermons gave the plot’s defeat an official place in the calendar.
Seventeenth century; 1673 in particular Pope and devil effigies developed; the 1673 example shows crowds displaying a Pope effigy.
1776 An engraving depicts a large public bonfire gathering with fireworks, without settling its effigy or participants’ motives.
Later eighteenth century and 1800s Paraded “Guys” and collecting customs appear in accounts; Fawkes becomes the familiar bonfire figure in the nineteenth century.
Today Bonfires and fireworks remain prominent, sometimes with a Fawkes effigy, while mainstream descriptions put much less emphasis on anti-Catholic meaning.


Conclusion

November commemoration began as an official thanksgiving for the survival of king and Parliament. Over time, popular celebrations acquired practices that could express anti-Catholic hostility, especially Pope-effigy burning. Later, the Guy Fawkes figure became more prominent, and modern Bonfire Night is often centred on a shared spectacle rather than the religious conflict of 1605. The dates and images reveal overlapping practices and changing emphases, not a clean succession of wholly separate festivals.

The next lesson follows a further change in Fawkes’s image: his portrayal as a symbol of resistance in fiction and protest, a meaning that needs to be distinguished from the historical plotters’ aims.