Welcome back. The previous lesson followed the changing meaning of 5 November: an official thanksgiving became, in many places, a night of effigies, fireworks, and popular entertainment. This final lesson follows a different change. Instead of burning a figure called “the Guy,” some people now wear his face to signal resistance.
Allow about 35–40 minutes. You will look at the image created for V for Vendetta, compare a key difference between its comic and film adaptation, and examine how protesters adopted the mask. Throughout, keep the historical plot in view: using Fawkes’s image is not the same as sharing the aims of Fawkes and his fellow conspirators.
How a condemned plotter became an anti-hero
The change did not begin with the mask. The London Museum notes that an 1841 historical novel helped portray Fawkes as a flawed, romantic anti-hero. Fiction could invite sympathy for someone whom the November celebrations had long represented as a traitor. That was an opening for reinterpretation, not yet the modern image of Fawkes as a general symbol of protest.
Read the museum’s short account of that intermediate stage and its account of V for Vendetta. The museum dates the graphic novel to 1988; its central character, V, is a fictional anarchist fighting a fictional authoritarian state.
The symbolism of Guy Fawkes | London Museum
Read the London Museum’s account to see how portrayals of Fawkes changed before the mask appeared at protests.
In “Fawkes became an anti-hero,” read the novel account, from the paragraph beginning with Ainsworth’s name through the sentence about popular culture. Then, in “A symbol of resistance,” read the comic account, from the introduction of the graphic novel through the paragraph on its growing protest symbolism. Focus on what each work made of Fawkes, rather than treating either fictional character as a historical portrait.
Now look at the graphic novel cover. Its dominant feature is not a scene from 1605 but a stylised face. The expression can be reproduced, worn, and recognised even by someone who knows little about the Gunpowder Plot.

V borrows Fawkes’s association with a planned attack on Parliament, but the fiction gives that association a new setting and purpose: opposition to an authoritarian regime. David Lloyd, who designed the comic’s mask, later described V as adopting the persona of “our great historical revolutionary.” That is revealing language from a creator of the fiction. It tells us how the character was conceived, not what the 1605 plotters intended.
What changes between the comic and the film
A comic can build a symbol around one masked character. A film can place that same mask on thousands of faces. The distinction matters because the film’s culminating crowd makes it especially easy to read V’s mask as something anyone can wear.
CineFix’s comparison uses excerpts and images from both versions. Watch only the indicated passages; the ending is discussed openly.
V for Vendetta - What's the Difference?
Watch selected passages from CineFix’s “V for Vendetta – What’s the Difference?” to compare how the comic and film use buildings, V’s legacy, and a masked crowd.
Watch the early scenes for the different buildings destroyed near the beginning. Then watch the comic ending and the film ending. The comparison shows Evey taking up V’s identity in the comic, while the film places a large masked crowd before Parliament and ends with the line “He was all of us.” Watch the comparison for the commentator’s interpretation of that difference. Attend to the scenes and images as evidence; the commentator’s judgments about their meaning remain interpretations.
In the comic, V destroys the Houses of Parliament early in the story; its ending places particular weight on Evey assuming his masked identity. The film uses Parliament’s destruction as its climax and shows an unarmed crowd wearing matching masks. Both versions suggest that an identity can outlast one person. The film makes collective identification far more visually immediate: a solitary face has become a crowd’s face.
Neither version is simply a celebration of the historical plot. Their imagined conflict concerns rule by a fictional authoritarian state. Nor does an image of an unarmed crowd erase the violence carried out by V within the story. The mask is powerful partly because viewers can emphasise different aspects of it: defiance, anonymity, shared identity, or a troubling association with attacks on political institutions.
From screen image to protest mask
BBC News traces how the mask moved beyond the story. Its article brings together Lloyd’s explanation, a comics commentator’s comparison of book and film, and accounts of its use in protests. Read those perspectives as attributed claims, not as one settled explanation for every person who wears the mask.
V for Vendetta masks: Who's behind them? - BBC News
Read the BBC News account to follow the mask from fiction into protests and to compare different explanations of its appeal.
In the article “V for Vendetta masks: Who’s behind them?”, begin with the paragraph starting “They were thought to have been used first.” Read the film-to-protest account through the commentator’s explanation of anonymity at Scientology protests. Along the way, find the film still immediately after the paragraph about a masked crowd marching on Parliament; compare it with the graphic novel cover above. Later, below the photograph of a masked protester at St Paul’s Cathedral, read a wearer’s explanation. Finally, read the caution about what the image might suggest to others.
The BBC reports that Anonymous used the masks during protests against Scientology in 2008; the image subsequently appeared in other movements, including Occupy protests. It served at least two practical and expressive purposes. A mask could conceal an individual’s face, while its instantly recognisable design could identify that person with a wider group. Lloyd suggested that Anonymous needed an image that could do both.
Those functions do not produce a single political programme. A protester quoted by the BBC associates the mask with opposition to corporate greed. A commentator stresses that the film’s crowd, more than the comic’s solitary V, helps explain its widespread adoption. The same commentator also warns that others may see a violent image rather than a symbol of peaceful dissent. These are different readings of one object, and wearing it alone does not establish which reading its wearer holds.

The photograph illustrates a limit of visual evidence. We can identify the mask and the badge; we cannot infer from them that this person belongs to Anonymous, endorses V’s actions, or admires the historical Fawkes. The mask makes a person both conspicuous and difficult to identify. Its meaning depends on the event, the wearer, and the audience interpreting it.
The historical distinction that holds the story together
The symbol has crossed several boundaries. The 1605 conspirators planned to kill James I and members of Parliament and bring about a change of regime connected to their Catholic hopes. Robert Catesby led the conspiracy; Fawkes’s assigned role centred on the explosives. The plan was not a campaign for a modern, broadly shared right to protest.
The V for Vendetta creators took a recognisable element of that history—a man associated with an attempted explosion at Parliament—and placed it in a fictional struggle against authoritarian rule. The film then offered a particularly memorable image of ordinary people sharing his mask. Protesters could adopt that image for aims of their own, without adopting either the conspirators’ religious project or every action of the fictional V.
This is more precise than saying that Fawkes “became a hero.” It identifies who recast him, which feature they retained, and what new meaning they gave it. It also leaves room for disagreement: one viewer may see resistance to tyranny, while another sees the danger of romanticising political violence.
Conclusion
Fawkes’s modern protest image is a reinterpretation, not a recovery of his original intentions. Nineteenth-century fiction helped make him an anti-hero; V for Vendetta gave a fictional rebel a reproducible Fawkes mask; the film made that mask a striking image of collective resistance; and groups including Anonymous used it for anonymity and public identity. Across those settings, the same face acquired meanings that the plotters of 1605 did not share.
That completes the course’s arc from religious politics and conspiracy, through discovery and commemoration, to popular culture. Keeping the historical plan separate from its later images makes both the history and the images more intelligible.