Welcome to the evidence-testing module. Earlier parts of the course examined how subsidies, procurement decisions, and entry rules can create advantages. Here the task is narrower: select the public records that could test a particular claim of favoritism. A useful investigation does not begin with a party label or a list of suspicious names. It begins with a claim precise enough that records might support it—or undermine it.
This lesson uses U.S. federal spending and lobbying records as a concrete example. The same method applies elsewhere, although disclosure rules and available records differ. Allow about 40 minutes, including the short video and selected readings.
Turn an allegation into a records plan
Consider a hypothetical claim: An equipment supplier with a political connection won a federal contract because the agency wrote unusually narrow requirements for it.
That sentence contains several distinct propositions. The supplier must be identified correctly; the alleged connection must be established; the agency must have adopted the requirements; and those requirements must have mattered to the award. Even if all four are true, the requirements might still have a defensible technical purpose.
A records plan therefore follows the claim’s links rather than collecting every document associated with the supplier:
| Link to test | Records worth seeking | What they can establish |
|---|---|---|
| Who benefited? | Award and recipient records; corporate ownership or control disclosures where public | The awardee’s identity and possible relationships to other entities |
| What was the connection or attempted influence? | Lobbying registrations and activity reports; relevant public financial or contribution disclosures | A disclosed client, issue, contact with an agency, or financial relationship |
| What did government decide? | Solicitation and amendments, eligibility rules, award notice, stated selection rationale | The requirements and the documented decision |
| What was the economic reward? | Award transactions, contract terms and modifications, or subsidy terms | The obligation, scope, pricing terms, and subsequent changes |
The columns are deliberately different. An award database is good evidence that an award was recorded; it is not, by itself, evidence that specifications were tailored. A lobbying report can show reported activity on an issue; it cannot tell you what an official privately thought. Select a record for the proposition it can actually test.
Establish the award and identify the recipient
Start with the public decision that supposedly delivered the benefit. USAspending’s introductory video shows where individual federal awards sit within broader spending data and how to find them.
Getting Started with USAspending.gov
Watch “Getting Started with USAspending.gov” from USAspending to orient yourself to award searches and recipient records.
Watch account versus award data to distinguish agency-wide totals from individual awards. Continue through award search for the filters, then profiles and downloads for ways to inspect recipients and retrieve more detailed data. Focus on locating a specific award, not interpreting a spending total as proof of favoritism.
The distinction between contracts and financial assistance determines which records to seek next. A contract purchases goods or services for an agency; financial assistance, including grants, serves an authorized public purpose. A supplier’s contract points you toward procurement specifications and selection records. A grant allegation points you toward program eligibility rules, applications or scoring records if available, and award conditions.
The Analyst’s Guide to Federal Spending Data clarifies three further distinctions: a prime recipient is not necessarily the final entity doing all the work; the office administering an award may differ from its funding agency; and a recipient’s parent-entity field is useful for grouping related awardees but does not identify every human owner.
Analyst’s Guide to Federal Spending Data | USAspending
Read these selections from USAspending’s analyst guide to determine which award and recipient records fit a claim.
In “Award Spending,” under “What is a prime award? What is a sub-award?” and “What are the two major categories of award spending?”, read award types. In “Agency Data Elements,” begin at “What is the difference between an awarding agency and a funding agency?” and continue through “Which fields in USAspending download files contain awarding agency identifier information?” Read agency identifiers. Finally, in “Recipient Data Elements,” begin at “How are recipients identified?” and continue through the parent-recipient explanation under “Which fields in USAspending download files contain recipient identifier information?” Read recipient identifiers. Focus on entity matching, not on the guide’s older discussion of DUNS: UEI is the current federal identifier.
For the hypothetical supplier, record the award identifier, recipient name and UEI, awarding office, award type, date, and amount. Check whether the record is a prime award or a sub-award; the company you care about may have received work through a prime contractor rather than directly from the government. Also distinguish an initial award from later modifications. A current award total may combine multiple transactions, while the amount initially committed may have been smaller.
Then test the identity claim separately. A shared name is not enough to match businesses reliably, and a parent recipient is not necessarily a beneficial owner. Relevant corporate filings or ownership disclosures, where public, may connect an awardee to another company or person. Public financial or conflict-of-interest disclosures, where applicable, may help test a claimed link to an official. Some ownership information is not public; if that link cannot be verified, mark it unverified rather than filling the gap with an assumption.
Match the alleged influence to the decision
A statement such as “the company lobbied the government” is too broad to test whether lobbying concerned this decision. You need a client, an issue, an agency or legislative body, and a reporting period. Federal lobbying disclosures provide some of that information.
LOBBYING DISCLOSURE ACT GUIDANCE Table of Contents
Read the Senate and House guidance to understand what lobbying filings can reveal—and what they leave unresolved. This guidance describes the filings’ structure; use current filing rules when investigating a present-day case.
In Section 6, “Quarterly Reporting of Lobbying Activities,” find “Quarterly Reporting of Lobbying Activities: Contents of Report” (pp. 19–20). Read LD-2 contents. Notice the difference between a specific reported issue and proof of influence over an award. Then, in Section 7, “Semiannual Reporting of Certain Contributions,” find “Semiannual Reporting of Certain Contributions: Contents of Report” (pp. 23–24). Read LD-203 contents for the kinds of reportable payments and contributions this filing covers.
The LD-1 registration identifies a registrant and client; LD-2 quarterly reports describe reported issues, federal agencies or houses of Congress contacted, and participating lobbyists; LD-203 reports cover certain contributions and payments. For the supplier claim, an LD-2 naming the relevant client, procurement-related issue, and agency before the requirements changed would make the proposed influence path more specific. It would not show that a lobbyist requested a particular specification—or that the agency accepted the request.
Timing matters, but so do reporting limits. A quarterly filing may not date an individual conversation, and activity that does not meet disclosure requirements may be absent. Conversely, a reported contribution or meeting is not evidence of an exchange for an award. Treat these records as ways to test contact and chronology, not as automatic verdicts.
Seek the decision record, not just the spending record
Suppose the award record confirms that the supplier won. The claim’s crucial phrase remains “the agency wrote unusually narrow requirements for it.” To test that phrase, prioritize the solicitation, its amendments, and any publicly available award decision or justification. Compare the original requirements with later versions. Identify the feature alleged to exclude rivals, when it appeared, and the agency’s stated reason for it.
Bid and evaluation information, where available, can test whether other suppliers could qualify and whether the winner was selected under the announced criteria. A justification for limited competition may explain urgency, compatibility, or the absence of alternatives. Such a justification deserves examination rather than automatic acceptance or dismissal. Some bids, evaluations, and procurement-file material may be withheld or redacted; an investigator must not imply access to records that are not public.
Finally, inspect contract terms and modifications where available. The award amount alone does not tell you whether the price was excessive or the terms unusually favorable. Scope of work, pricing provisions, performance requirements, option periods, and later changes can alter the benefit. Meaningful comparisons require similar goods or services, quantities, timing, and contract conditions. The recorded award or obligation is also not necessarily the same as money already paid out.
The public-interest explanation needs records too. Technical requirements might be narrow because equipment must work with an existing system; a grant might be restricted because legislation defines its eligible recipients. The appropriate selection is therefore not merely “records about the winner,” but the governing rules, the decision record, and comparable outcomes for other eligible parties.
Put the records in an order that can change your mind
For the hypothetical contract, an efficient investigation would proceed as follows:
- Fix the claim’s scope. Identify the supplier, agency, approximate period, alleged connection, and allegedly tailored requirement.
- Confirm the reward. Use award and transaction records to establish who received what, from which awarding office, and when.
- Verify the connection. Match entity identifiers and consult relevant public ownership, financial, or lobbying disclosures. Keep indirect or unverified links distinct from confirmed ones.
- Inspect the decision. Obtain the solicitation versions, award notice, available selection rationale, and contract terms or modifications. Check the agency’s stated purpose alongside the claimed advantage.
- Look for comparisons and missing records. Other qualified bidders, comparable awards, and the timing of rule changes can challenge either explanation. Record unavailable material as a limitation.
This order prevents a common error: discovering a connection and then treating every subsequent award as its consequence. The record set should be capable of revealing a routine competitive decision as well as an unfair advantage.
Conclusion
To test a favoritism claim, select records for identity, influence, public decision, and economic reward—then add the rules and comparisons needed to assess a legitimate alternative explanation. Award databases establish recorded recipients and transactions; lobbying filings help specify reported activity; ownership disclosures may verify a connection; and decision files and contract terms are needed to examine how an advantage arose. None of these records alone proves favoritism, and missing or nonpublic records should remain visible uncertainties.
The next lesson will take the further step of distinguishing a relationship that merely coincides with a business reward from evidence that the relationship helped cause it.