Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 7

Distinguishing Types of Memory in Memory Studies

Recommended resources

Welcome to the memory module. Earlier lessons separated voluntary imagery from perception and examined how researchers measure imagery. Now the focus shifts to memory. A person might know that an event happened, recall what it felt like, or identify a photograph from it; those are related achievements, but a study may measure only one of them.

This lesson gives you a way to read memory-study descriptions precisely. You will distinguish recollection of a personal episode, knowledge of facts, and recognition of something encountered before—without assuming that a mental picture is required for all three.


A memory of an event is not just a fact about it

Consider two statements about the same occasion:

“I attended a concert during the summer.”

“When the lights dimmed, I heard someone behind me cheer, felt the floor vibrate, and remember being startled.”

The first conveys autobiographical factual knowledge: information about your life that you can state without mentally revisiting a particular moment. The second describes episodic recollection: details tied to a specific event, including perception, action, and feeling. Both statements may be true and useful. They tell us different things about how the past is available to the person reporting it.

Psychologists often place episodic and semantic memory within explicit, or declarative, long-term memory: information that can be consciously reported. Episodic memory concerns particular experiences; semantic memory concerns knowledge and facts. Semantic knowledge can be personal—“I went to that concert”—as well as general—“Concerts often begin after an opening act.”

8.1 How Memory Functions - Psychology 2e

Read this OpenStax Psychology 2e introduction for the core distinctions between episodic and semantic memory, then between recall and recognition.

In “8.1 How Memory Functions,” begin with the paragraph opening “There are two types of long-term memory.” Read the memory distinctions through the examples of semantic knowledge; the definitions of episodic and semantic memory appear just after the “Link to Learning” callout. Later in the same section, find the paragraph opening “There are three ways you can retrieve information.” Read the retrieval examples. Focus on the difference between producing information and identifying it when it is presented.

The diagram below places episodic and semantic memory side by side. Its other branch is a useful reminder that long-term memory is broader than either: a practiced skill, for example, is not the same kind of memory as a narrated event.

Long-term memory divided into explicit memory (including episodic experiences and semantic knowledge) and implicit memory (including practiced skills and emotional conditioning). The lesson focuses on the two explicit categories and on ways of testing retrieval.

One qualification matters for this course. Descriptions of episodic memory often emphasize vivid visual scenes, but visual imagery is not the definition of having memory. Someone can report an event’s sequence, sounds, emotions, or other specific details without voluntarily seeing a picture of it. Conversely, a vivid image by itself does not establish that an event occurred.



What an autobiographical interview is trying to capture

Researchers cannot directly inspect another person’s experience of remembering. One approach is to ask for a narrative of a particular life event and examine what kinds of details the account contains. A general statement such as “We went to that park often” sets the background. An account of one afternoon there—where someone stood, what happened next, what was heard, what the speaker felt—provides details of a bounded episode.

In the following short video passages, researcher Brian Levine explains why the subjective sense of revisiting an event matters and shows how an interview narrative can be broken down for study. The opening film scene is an illustration of an experience, not a test that every person’s memory must resemble.

What is SDAM? Memory Without Reliving It, and Its Link to Aphantasia | Dr. Brian Levine

Watch selected passages of “What is SDAM? Memory Without Reliving It, and Its Link to Aphantasia,” presented by Brian Levine on Aphantasia Network. They connect the experience of recollection with a method for studying event narratives.

Watch the illustration for Levine’s distinction between facts about the past and the felt experience of a recalled setting, time, and emotion. Then watch the interview example. Follow how the speaker’s recurring background circumstances are separated from details of one specific incident.

That separation becomes a coding rule in the Autobiographical Interview, a research method used in studies of aphantasia. Details belonging to the particular event being described are called internal. Details outside that event are called external. These labels refer to the interview’s target event, not to whether a detail is private or spoken aloud.

Hippocampal-occipital connectivity reflects autobiographical memory deficits in aphantasia

Read the scoring description in this research paper to see how an autobiographical account is turned into categories of measurable details. The purpose here is to understand the measure, not yet to judge the study’s group results.

Find the paragraph about scoring memory details immediately before the “Debriefing questions” heading. Read the scoring rules. Pay particular attention to the lists of internal and external subcategories. Notice that internal details include more than visual perception, while external details include more than factual knowledge alone.

The scoring rule is subtler than “episodic equals sensory” and “semantic equals everything else.” Internal details may concern the event’s actions, place, time, perceptions, or thoughts and emotions. External details may include general knowledge, repeated information, or a different specific event brought up while telling the main story.

For example, in an account of one train journey, “I heard the doors close while I was still looking for a seat” is tied to the target event. “I took that route every weekday” describes a recurring fact and provides context. “The week before, I missed a different train” may itself describe a specific episode, but it is external to the journey being scored. This is why a study’s count of “external details” should not automatically be translated as a complete test of someone’s semantic-memory ability.

A detail’s content also needs its context. “The station was on the north side of town” might be a fact the speaker knows independently of that day. “I turned toward the north exit when I heard the announcement” describes an action in the particular remembered event. Coding rules help researchers distinguish these cases consistently; they do not turn every reported detail into proof that the memory is accurate.



Recognition is a way of testing memory, not a rival category of life events

Imagine a researcher showing a participant photographs, then later mixing those photographs with new ones. The participant marks which were shown before. That is a recognition-memory task: the item is present, and the participant identifies whether it was encountered previously. By contrast, asking the participant to describe the photographs without showing them calls for recall. An interviewer may still offer a cue or follow-up prompt during recall; the key difference is that the person must supply remembered content rather than identify a presented answer.

This gives us two separate distinctions:

What is being studied? What might a test ask the person to do?
Knowledge or semantic content State a learned fact, or recognize the correct answer among alternatives.
A particular episode Narrate what happened during one event, or recognize an item encountered during that event.

A recognition task can yield a correct answer without showing how the person arrived at it. The item might feel familiar, or its appearance might prompt recollection of its earlier context. Correct recognition alone does not demonstrate vivid reliving. Likewise, struggling to narrate an event does not imply an inability to recognize things encountered before.

Levine makes this distinction using research on severely deficient autobiographical memory (SDAM), a condition discussed in relation to—but not identical with—aphantasia.

What is SDAM? Memory Without Reliving It, and Its Link to Aphantasia | Dr. Brian Levine

Return to Levine’s video for a brief example of why a person’s experience of recollection and performance on a recognition task should not be treated as interchangeable.

Watch recognition performance. Focus on the contrast between limited subjective reliving in the people Levine discusses and their ability to identify previously presented items. The example concerns SDAM; do not treat it as a result for every person with aphantasia.

When reading a memory study, the task description is therefore as important as its use of the word memory. “Recognized previously shown objects,” “recalled facts about an occasion,” and “produced perceptual details from one past event” describe different observations. None is a stand-alone measure of all memory.



A compact reading rule for the studies ahead

When a study reports a memory difference, first identify the target: a particular personal event, knowledge that can be stated as a fact, or previously encountered material. Then identify the response demanded: an open narrative, a factual answer, or recognition among presented items. Finally, keep performance and experience apart. The number of details reported, the correctness of an answer, and the feeling of reliving measure related but non-equivalent aspects of remembering.

The key distinction is not between “has memory” and “has no memory.” It is between kinds of information and ways that researchers make them observable. In the next lesson, you will use these distinctions to evaluate reported differences in autobiographical recollection in aphantasia, without turning reduced vividness or fewer reported details into a claim of general inability to remember.