Hello. In the previous lessons, you separated sexual attraction from libido and arousal, then distinguished sexual attraction from romantic, aesthetic, and sensual attraction. One further distinction completes this module: what someone does sexually is not a reliable test of what attraction they experience or which identity they use.
This lesson examines three cases that often lead to mistaken conclusions—abstinence, masturbation, and partnered sex. Allow about 30–35 minutes, including the short reading and video clips.
Abstinence describes an action, not an orientation
A person can be sexually attracted to someone and decide not to have sex with them. They might be following a personal or religious commitment, setting a boundary, waiting for a particular relationship, or simply not wanting sex at that time. Another person might not have sex because they rarely or never experience sexual attraction. The outward behavior may look identical; the experiences behind it need not be.
The Trevor Project’s Understanding Asexuality: FAQs & Supportive Resources makes the central distinction between attraction and behavior. Read its brief comparison before considering a qualification below.
Understanding Asexuality: FAQs & Supportive Resources
Read the Trevor Project’s FAQ for its distinction between asexuality and refraining from sex.
Find the heading “What’s the difference between asexuality, celibacy, and abstinence?” Read the comparison, from the paragraph beginning “Although asexuality” through its final sentence about refraining from sexual contact. Focus on which terms describe attraction or identity and which describe behavior.
Asexuality describes an experience of little or no sexual attraction and an identity someone may use for that experience. Celibacy generally describes an intentional commitment not to engage in sex. Abstinence describes refraining from sexual activity, often by choice and sometimes for a particular period. These terms answer different questions. A person can be asexual and abstinent, or sexually attracted to others and abstinent.
There is a useful limit to the word choice here. Not having sex is not always a deliberate commitment: someone might have no available partner, be recovering from illness, or face other circumstances. Even when a person does choose abstinence, that choice tells you what they have decided to do, not whom they find sexually attractive. “They have never had sex” therefore establishes neither asexuality nor any other orientation.
Masturbation does not require attraction to someone else
The same reasoning applies when sexual activity occurs alone. In the previous lessons, libido was a general sexual drive, bodily arousal was a physical response, and sexual attraction was a pull toward a person. Masturbation may relate to the first two without implying the third.
In Asexuality & Masturbation with Taryn!, from What’s My Body Doing, an asexual guest discusses reasons someone might masturbate. Treat this as one person’s account of possible motivations, not as a description of every asexual person.
Asexuality & Masturbation with Taryn! | What's My Body Doing
Watch the short discussion in Asexuality & Masturbation with Taryn! for a first-person example of why masturbation need not indicate sexual attraction.
Watch the guest’s answer, from the question about solo pleasure through her explanation of physical pleasure. Notice that she also says people in both asexual and non-asexual groups may choose not to masturbate.
Someone may masturbate because stimulation feels pleasant, to relax, or in response to arousal that is not directed at anyone. Another person may masturbate while feeling attracted to someone. The behavior alone does not distinguish those experiences. Equally, not masturbating does not establish an absence of sexual attraction: preference, circumstance, and personal boundaries can all affect behavior.
This is why “but they masturbate” does not disprove someone’s asexual identity. It reports an action, while the identity concerns how they experience attraction. Neither masturbation nor its absence provides a shortcut around what the person says about themselves.
Partnered sex has more than one possible meaning
Partnered sex may seem like stronger evidence of attraction because another person is involved. Yet taking part in an activity with someone and feeling a sexual pull toward them remain distinct. A person might want partnered sex because they are attracted to their partner. They might also value closeness, enjoy the physical experience, feel curious, or hope to conceive without experiencing that pull.
The selected passage of Could You Be Asexual? An Overview of One of the Rarest Orientations, by Meghan Sandor-Schielke, gives several examples of why an asexual person might choose to have sex. The clip’s point is about possible motivations, not an expectation that asexual people should have sex.
Could You Be Asexual? An Overview of One of the Rarest Orientations
Watch this short excerpt for examples that separate participation in partnered sex from attraction to a partner.
At possible motivations, the speaker lists reasons some asexual people may choose partnered sex and states that doing so does not invalidate an asexual identity. Stop when the discussion turns to subcategories on the asexual spectrum.
Consider two people who each have sex with a partner. One reports, “I feel sexually drawn to my partner.” The other reports, “I don’t experience that pull, but I wanted to share this experience.” Their behavior does not erase the difference between their accounts. Nor does enjoyment afterward prove that both experienced attraction beforehand: finding an experience pleasurable and being sexually attracted to a particular person are separate claims.
These examples describe possibilities, not obligations. Someone does not need to have partnered sex to show care for a partner, and a partner’s wishes do not establish consent. A person who has sex without experiencing attraction may have chosen it freely; another may not have wanted it. Neither attraction nor lack of attraction tells you whether a particular encounter was wanted. The course will examine consent more directly later.
The gender of a person’s partner also cannot, by itself, settle their orientation. A relationship or sexual encounter reveals something about what happened, but not the full pattern of attraction someone experiences or the label they use. Inferring “straight,” “gay,” “bisexual,” or “asexual” solely from a partner’s gender or a sexual act reaches beyond the evidence.
Why the inference fails
The common error in all three cases is treating an observable behavior as though it had only one explanation. Abstinence can coexist with sexual attraction or with little or none. Masturbation can occur with or without attraction to another person. Partnered sex can likewise take place for different reasons. Knowing the behavior does not reveal which explanation applies to a particular person.
It helps to keep three levels distinct:
| Level | What it tells you |
|---|---|
| Behavior | What someone did or did not do, such as abstaining, masturbating, or having partnered sex. |
| Attraction | How they experience a sexual pull toward people, if they do. |
| Identity | The term, if any, they use to describe themselves. |
These levels can relate to one another without being interchangeable. A person may choose behavior partly because of attraction, but behavior also reflects boundaries, opportunities, relationships, and other motivations. Identity is a person’s own description, not a label that an observer can establish by tallying acts. People may also change their behavior without thereby changing their orientation, and the words they use for themselves may evolve as they understand their experience.
When someone shares an identity, a respectful response is to use their term rather than try to confirm or refute it with a behavioral checklist. When they have not shared an identity, it is more accurate to describe only what you know: “They said they are not having sex,” for example, rather than “They must be asexual.” Leaving an unknown unknown is more precise than guessing.
Key takeaways
Abstinence, masturbation, and partnered sex describe behavior; none establishes sexual orientation or identity. Similar actions can reflect different experiences of attraction and different motivations. Conversely, people who use the same identity may make different choices about sexual activity. The reliable distinction is between what someone does, what attraction they report, and how they describe themselves.
Next, the course turns to asexuality in more detail, beginning with why little or no sexual attraction should not be confused with an assumed absence of libido, arousal, or relationships.