Hello. The previous lesson examined limits on individual clemency grants: the governor must act within state jurisdiction, after sentencing, and sometimes with a California Supreme Court recommendation. This final lesson changes the question from “Can the governor take this action?” to “How long can the governor remain in office?”
California answers that second question through regular elections, a two-term limit, and voter-initiated recall. These checks on tenure are distinct from judicial review, which can stop an unlawful executive action without removing the governor. Allow about 35–40 minutes for the lesson and its two short official readings.
Regular elections and the two-term limit
The starting rule is in the California Constitution. Read Article V, Section 2 with particular attention to the election interval, when a newly elected governor takes office, and the final sentence.
Read the constitutional provision to establish the ordinary length and outer limit of a governor's tenure.
In Article V, Section 2, read the full provision. Notice the distinction between an election every fourth year and the separate prohibition on serving more than two terms.
A governor faces voters at a regularly scheduled election every four years. Winning one election does not guarantee another term: voters can choose someone else at the next one. The Constitution also says that no governor may serve more than two terms. That is not merely a requirement to sit out an election after two consecutive terms; the provision does not permit a third term.
These rules constrain the office in different ways. Regular elections give voters periodic opportunities to choose who governs. The term limit prevents an incumbent from continuing to seek the office indefinitely, even if that incumbent remains popular. Neither rule makes every decision taken during a term provisional. For example, losing a later election does not, by itself, cancel an earlier lawful commutation or undo a law the governor signed.
Recall: an election before the term ends
Four years can be a long time to wait if voters want to remove an officeholder sooner. Recall provides a separate electoral route: voters can initiate a process that may end an elected official’s term early. The Secretary of State’s recall guide identifies the governor as an officeholder subject to recall.
PROCEDURE FOR RECALLING STATE AND LOCAL ...
Read the California Secretary of State's recall guide for the distinction between starting a recall campaign and qualifying an election.
In Chapter I, “General Recall Provisions” (p. 4), read from “Recall is the power of the voters” through the list that includes the Governor in the definition. Then use Chapter II, “Recall of State Officers.” Under “The Notice of Intention” (p. 6), read the opening procedure, ending with the statement about the reason given for recall. Under “Determine the Number of Signatures Required,” at “Statewide Officer” (p. 11), read the signature rule. Finally, on p. 12, find the paragraph beginning “After determining that the proponents have obtained sufficient signatures” and read through certification.
The distinction between a petition and an election matters. Recall proponents begin with a notice stating a reason for seeking removal. They must then obtain enough valid petition signatures to qualify a recall election. For a statewide officer such as the governor, the guide specifies signatures equal to 12 percent of the last vote for that office, with a further distribution requirement across at least five counties. Once sufficient signatures are certified, voters—not petition signers alone—decide whether the governor is removed.
Proponents must state a reason, but they do not have to prove that the governor committed a legal violation or persuade a court that their reason is politically sufficient. Voters may oppose a governor’s lawful decisions and seek recall on that basis. The petition requirements are therefore a threshold for putting removal to a vote, not a legal finding against the governor.
The election itself has two distinct decisions. Read the guide’s account before considering what each result means.
PROCEDURE FOR RECALLING STATE AND LOCAL ...
Continue with the Secretary of State's guide to see how voters decide removal and, if removal succeeds, choose a successor.
In Chapter IV, “The Recall Election,” under “In General” (pp. 23–24), read from “At the election, voters will decide” through the description of choosing a successor in the ballot overview. On p. 24, read the paragraph beginning “If a majority of the votes on a recall proposal are” through the rule for the unexpired term in the result rule.
Voters first decide whether to recall the governor. If a majority votes yes, the governor is removed. Voters also choose a replacement; if the recall succeeds, the replacement candidate with the highest number of votes serves the unexpired portion of the term. The replacement need not receive a majority in a field with multiple candidates. If the recall fails, the governor stays in office, and the replacement choice does not take effect.
Thus, filing a recall petition does not remove a governor, and qualifying a recall election does not remove one either. Removal depends on the voters’ decision at the recall election.
Removing an officeholder is not invalidating an action
Earlier in the course, judicial review supplied a different kind of check. A court can rule that a gubernatorial action exceeds authority granted by law or violates the California or U.S. Constitution. Its focus is the legality of the action, not whether voters prefer the governor’s policies. A court may block the action while the governor remains in office.
Elections and recall ask a different question: Who should hold the office? Voters can replace a governor after a regular term or remove one through recall without first obtaining a court ruling that any executive action was unlawful. Conversely, a court can invalidate an unlawful action even when voters continue to support the governor.
Consider two decisions made by the same governor. The governor grants a commutation within the constitutional limits studied in the previous lesson, but many voters strongly disapprove. That disagreement alone does not make the commutation unlawful; voters can nevertheless take it into account in an election or recall. Separately, suppose the governor directs spending that the Legislature has not authorized. A court could block that direction for exceeding legal authority, regardless of whether voters approve of the governor. Blocking the spending direction would not, by itself, remove the governor.
| Check | What it primarily decides | Direct effect |
|---|---|---|
| Regular election | Who serves the next term | Voters choose the next governor |
| Two-term limit | Whether a governor may serve another term | Prevents service beyond two terms |
| Recall election | Whether a governor leaves before the term ends | A successful recall removes the governor and provides for a successor |
| Judicial review | Whether a particular action is lawful | A court can block or invalidate the action without removing the governor |
These checks can operate alongside the legislative limits discussed earlier in the course. The Legislature’s control over legislation and appropriations limits what a governor can accomplish while in office. Elections, term limits, and recall constrain continued occupancy of the office. Courts assess whether particular actions stay within legal boundaries.
Key takeaways
California elects its governor every four years and permits no governor to serve more than two terms. Recall gives voters a way to remove a governor before a term ends, but a petition must qualify for an election and voters must approve removal. Neither an election loss nor a successful recall automatically invalidates an earlier action. That is a different question from judicial review, which tests an action’s legality and can block it without ending the governor’s tenure.
Across the course, the central distinction is between authority to act and authority to remain in office. Constitutional rules, the Legislature, and courts constrain the first; elections, the term limit, and recall constrain the second.