Welcome to the module on Marx’s account of capitalism and communism. The earlier module separated ownership, class, and economic coordination into distinct questions. Here the focus narrows to one claim about capitalist production: why did Marx think an employer could pay the agreed wage, sell a product at its value, and still obtain a surplus? Understanding that claim will make the next lesson, on class conflict, easier to follow.
This lesson presents Marx’s explanation, not a test of whether every part of his theory is correct. You will first examine what a wage buys, then use a simple production example to distinguish the value of the finished product, the worker’s wage, and surplus value.
A wage buys the capacity to work
Imagine a workshop whose owner supplies materials and equipment and hires a worker for a day. The worker does not sell a finished product to the owner. In Marx’s terminology, the worker sells labour-power: the capacity to work for the agreed period. Labour is that capacity in use—the work actually performed.
The ownership arrangement matters. The owner controls the production process and owns its output, while the worker receives a wage. Marx treats the wage contract as a real exchange, not a pretence: his question is how a surplus can arise even if the owner pays the full assumed value of the labour-power purchased.
Economic Manuscripts: Capital Vol. I - Chapter Seven
Read the end of Section 1 of Marx’s Capital to see how he connects the wage contract to control of the work and ownership of its product.
In Section 1, “The Labour-Process or the Production of Use-Values,” go to the final discussion of the capitalist’s workshop. Begin where Marx describes control and ownership, ending with his comparison to wine produced in a cellar. Focus on his two claims: who directs the work, and who owns what is made.
For a visual introduction to the next distinction, watch the following explanation. It presents Marx’s theory from a Marxist perspective; use it to understand the argument rather than as independent evidence that any particular firm’s profit has this source.
Fundamentals of Marx: Surplus Labor and Value
“Fundamentals of Marx: Surplus Labor and Value,” from The Marxist Project, uses a T-shirt factory to introduce labour-power and surplus value.
Watch labour-power for the distinction between hiring a worker and buying other production inputs. Continue through production and value, paying attention to the roles of materials, work, and the finished commodity. In the workday example, notice how the explanation divides working time into the portion that replaces the wage and the portion that creates a surplus.
What gets transferred, and what gets added?
To see why the wage is not simply deducted from the selling price and called “exploitation,” separate two sources of the product’s value in Marx’s account.
Materials and used-up equipment already have value. In production, that value is transferred to the new product. Marx calls this constant capital, commonly written . If a machine lasts many days, the relevant amount is the value of its wear during this production, not its entire purchase price.
The worker’s activity adds new value. The wage paid for labour-power is variable capital, . Marx’s central claim is that labour-power can add more new value during a working day than the value paid for it as a wage. He calls the excess surplus value, . In the simplified case, the finished commodity’s value is:
This is an account of value under Marx’s assumptions, not a rule that every observed market price will equal that sum. It also prevents a common mistake: the entire product value is not value newly created by the worker during this particular day. Part of it came from materials and equipment made through earlier labour.

Marx makes the distinction concrete with a spinner. The older shilling amounts are useful because his example first fails to produce a surplus.
Economic Manuscripts: Capital Vol. I - Chapter Seven
Return to Marx’s chapter for the first half of his yarn calculation. Read how he accounts for materials and equipment, then why the initial work period leaves the owner with no surplus.
In Section 2, “The Production of Surplus-Value,” find the discussion after “Let us now examine production as a creation of value.” Read from “For spinning the yarn, raw material is required” through the transferred value. Then skip ahead within the same section to “We assumed, on the occasion of its sale” and read through the first calculation. Track the 12 shillings for cotton and spindle wear, the 3-shilling wage, and the 15-shilling value of the yarn.
At this first stopping point, the numbers balance. The cotton and spindle wear transfer 12 shillings of value. Six hours of spinning add 3 shillings, equal to the wage. The yarn has a value of 15 shillings, exactly matching the 15 shillings advanced. There is no surplus value.
How the surplus appears
Marx’s next move is to keep the assumed daily wage at 3 shillings but extend production from six hours to twelve. The spinner uses twice as much cotton and spindle wear, so those inputs now transfer 24 shillings. Twelve hours of work add 6 shillings of new value. The owner has advanced 27 shillings—24 for inputs and 3 for labour-power—and the yarn has a value of 30 shillings.
Economic Manuscripts: Capital Vol. I - Chapter Seven
Read Marx’s explanation of why the daily cost of labour-power and the value created by a full day of labour can differ.
In Section 2, “The Production of Surplus-Value,” resume at “Let us examine the matter more closely.” Read the extended calculation through the paragraph ending “money has been converted into capital.” Then read the next explanation, from “Every condition of the problem is satisfied” through exchange and production. Notice that Marx assumes the inputs, including labour-power, were bought at their full values.
The two periods can now be compared without treating materials as if they were newly created by the spinner:
| Six hours | Twelve hours | |
|---|---|---|
| Value transferred from cotton and spindle wear | 12 shillings | 24 shillings |
| New value added by spinning | 3 shillings | 6 shillings |
| Daily wage | 3 shillings | 3 shillings |
| Surplus value | 0 | 3 shillings |
Marx calls the time whose new value is equivalent to the wage necessary labour time: six hours in this example. The additional six hours are surplus labour time; they create the 3 shillings of surplus value. These are accounting distinctions within the day. They do not mean that the worker’s wage contract literally pays for the first six hours and excludes the last six. The worker receives the agreed wage for the full day.
Here is the same relationship with simpler currency amounts. Suppose a workshop uses materials and equipment wear worth 120 currency units, pays a daily wage of 80, and sells its output at an assumed value of 280. If production adds 160 units of new value, then:
If eight hours add that new value at a steady rate, four hours add value equivalent to the wage and four add the surplus. The owner’s initial outlay is 200 units; the 80-unit difference is not obtained by counting the 120 units of materials as the worker’s new contribution.
What “exploitation” does—and does not—mean here
In this theory, exploitation names a relationship between wage labour and ownership: workers create new value exceeding the value of their labour-power, while owners of the productive assets appropriate the surplus. It does not require the owner to break the contract, cheat on wages, or sell above the commodity’s assumed value. Nor does it imply that a worker cannot receive a relatively high wage. Marx’s claim concerns the relationship between wage and newly created value.
Surplus value should also not be read straight off a company’s reported net profit. Actual prices can differ from values; selling, financing, and other costs complicate a firm’s accounts. The numerical examples deliberately set those complications aside to isolate Marx’s proposed source of surplus in production. Economists disagree about his theory of value and explanations of profit. Understanding his calculation is therefore distinct from accepting it as a complete account of real-world prices or profits.
Conclusion
Marx distinguishes the value of labour-power, paid as a wage, from the new value created when that capacity is put to work. Materials and equipment transfer existing value; labour adds new value. When the new value exceeds the wage, the excess is surplus value, appropriated by the owner under the arrangement Marx describes—even if the agreed wage is paid and the output sells at its assumed value.
The next lesson broadens this production-level account into Marx’s historical argument about class conflict: how relationships between owners and workers shape struggles over economic and political change.