Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 17

Evaluating Contested Socialism Through Primary and Scholarly Sources

Recommended resources

A welfare policy or a party name can tell you something important without settling how an entire society works. The same caution applies to historical texts: a revolutionary writer’s description of a future society is evidence of an aim, not proof that a government achieved it.

This lesson takes about 40 minutes. You will assess a contested claim about “communism” by reading Lenin’s own words alongside a later scholarly interpretation. The aim is not to find a label that ends the argument, but to reach a conclusion that fits the evidence.


A claim with two meanings

Consider the assertion: “A communist government is a contradiction in terms, because communism is stateless.” It has a strong point. In the envisioned classless, fully developed communist society, the state would no longer exist as an apparatus for one class to suppress another.

But communist government can also mean a government led by a party committed to communism, or a government claiming to oversee a transition toward it. Those uses do not assert that a stateless society has already arrived. Whether the government lives up to its claims is a further question.

To assess the assertion, keep two kinds of source apart. A primary source, written by a participant in the debate, helps establish what that participant argued. A scholarly account, written later, can place the argument in context, examine tensions within it, and compare it with subsequent developments. Neither kind of source automatically proves what happened throughout an economy or how much control ordinary workers exercised.



Read Lenin’s distinction in its original setting

Lenin wrote The State and Revolution in 1917, before the Bolsheviks took power. In Chapter 5 he discusses a political transition, an early phase of communist society, and a higher phase. He draws extensively on Marx; when he quotes Marx, distinguish Marx’s words from Lenin’s interpretation of them.

The State and Revolution — Chapter 5

Read Lenin’s account to identify precisely when he expects a state to remain and when he expects it to disappear. Pay particular attention to his use of both “socialism” and “communism” for the early phase.

In Chapter 5, Section 2, “The Transition from Capitalism to Communism,” begin at the paragraph opening “And the dictatorship of the proletariat.” Read the transition account through the paragraph that ends by calling the state a special apparatus for coercion. Notice the contrast between a transitional state and a classless society. In Section 3, “The First Phase of Communist Society,” start at “It is this communist society” and read the lower phase through Lenin’s contrast between distribution according to labour and distribution according to need. Then read the phase boundary, beginning at the end of Section 3 and continuing into Section 4, “The Higher Phase of Communist Society.” Finally, near the end of Section 4, after Lenin’s discussion of the “one huge” state-wide enterprise and his reply to a “learned professor,” read his terminological summary. Focus on why he says “communism” can apply to the lower phase without meaning complete communism.

Lenin does not describe the transition as immediately stateless. He argues for political rule by the working class, including suppression of the former exploiting class. In his account, the early phase has common ownership of the means of production, but distribution still depends largely on labour contributed, after provision for shared needs. He says this phase is usually called socialism, while Marx called it the lower phase of communist society. For Lenin, “communism” can therefore name that early phase, provided it is not confused with complete communism.

The higher phase is different. Lenin expects the class divisions that give a coercive state its purpose to disappear; distribution according to need becomes possible, and the state withers away. That distinction preserves the insight in the contested claim: complete communism is stateless in Lenin’s account. It also defeats the claim’s categorical wording. Lenin’s vocabulary permits talk of a state during a transition associated with communism.

Notice the limit of what you have established. This 1917 text tells you what Lenin proposed and predicted. Its account of common ownership and workers’ political rule does not demonstrate that later institutions gave workers effective control, or that the state actually diminished.



Read a scholar against—and with—the primary source

Political theorist Ralph Miliband’s 1970 article takes Lenin’s proposed workers’ state seriously, then presses on a difficulty: even if workers are meant to rule, political decisions require organization and leadership. Miliband calls this political mediation. His question is whether rule in the name of workers necessarily remains rule by workers when a party exercises that leadership.

Ralph Miliband: Lenin's "The State and Revolution" (1970)

Miliband offers a critical scholarly interpretation, not a neutral inventory of every institution that followed the revolution. Read for the point where his account of Lenin’s proposed state becomes a question about party power.

In the main body of the article, find the passage immediately after Miliband summarizes the proposed state of armed workers as already “at a stage of advanced decomposition.” Begin at “The first of these problems is that of the political mediation” and read the central argument through his comparison of the 1917 model with Lenin’s later assertions about party leadership. Track which statements describe the 1917 text, which are later statements Miliband cites, and which are Miliband’s judgments. Later in the same discussion, find the paragraph beginning “The temptation, it seems to me, ought to be resisted.” Within it, read the pluralism concern. Focus on his reason for distinguishing a party’s claim to represent workers from workers’ ability to express differing views.

Miliband sees a real tension, not merely a change of terminology. He describes The State and Revolution as envisioning a state in which armed workers supervise officials closely. He then cites Lenin’s statements after the seizure of power assigning the party an indispensable—and, in Miliband’s account, exclusive—political role. Miliband argues that this changes the problem: how can workers govern if the party, or its leadership, becomes the decisive authority?

This is an interpretation supported partly by later statements that Miliband quotes. It is not something you can simply read off Lenin’s Chapter 5. Miliband also writes from a position concerned with socialist democracy; his concern helps explain why he emphasizes alternative channels of political expression. Treat that perspective as a reason to examine his argument carefully, not to dismiss it or accept it without qualification.

The sources thus do different work. Lenin establishes the intended distinction between transitional and higher phases. Miliband tests a difficulty in realizing the proposed transition. Together they make it harder to infer either that a party label proves workers ruled or that the presence of a state makes every use of “communist” meaningless.



Apply the comparison to a public claim

The Soviet poster below is another primary source, but of a different kind. It presents Marx, Engels, Lenin, and Stalin as a continuous line of leaders above scenes of collective action. Its slogan calls on viewers to raise their banner. The poster is evidence of a political message and a claimed lineage, not a survey of ownership, class relations, or political control.

A Soviet propaganda poster places Marx, Engels, Lenin, and Stalin above revolutionary and Soviet scenes. Its call to raise their banner asserts ideological continuity; the image alone cannot establish how the depicted society was governed.

You can now give the contested assertion a more exact verdict. “Communism is stateless” is accurate if “communism” means the fully developed society Lenin describes. “A communist government is a contradiction in terms” does not follow, because “communist” may describe a party’s project or, in Lenin’s usage, an incomplete phase rather than the finished condition.

That verdict does not certify any government as a successful instance of workers’ rule. Lenin’s text states the theory; the poster promotes a lineage; Miliband identifies a potential—and, he argues, historically consequential—gap between workers’ rule and party rule. Establishing what happened in a particular society would require further evidence about who controlled productive assets, who made decisions, how production was coordinated, and who held political power. The name on a banner cannot supply those answers.



Conclusion

A sound assessment preserves both sides of the evidence. Lenin envisaged a stateless higher phase, but also described an earlier phase and a political transition in which a state remained. Miliband shows why calling that state a workers’ state does not settle who actually exercised power. The poster shows how a political movement could claim continuity with a tradition without demonstrating that it had fulfilled the tradition’s aims.

In the final lesson, you will bring this source-conscious approach together with the course’s four recurring criteria—ownership, class, markets, and the state—to evaluate a political comparison as a whole.