Hello. In the previous lesson, you treated a justice’s oral-argument question as a test of a legal position, not a prediction of the justice’s vote. Written opinions reveal the next stage: what the Court decided, which justices supported that result, and where they disagreed about the reasons.
This lesson gives you a way to classify an excerpt as a majority opinion, a concurrence, or a dissent. The key is to keep two things separate: the judgment—the Court’s disposition of the case—and the reasoning offered for it.
One case can produce several opinions
After deciding a case, the Court may publish more than one piece of writing about it. The Supreme Court’s own guide explains how those writings are presented together.
Opinions - Supreme Court of the United States
Read the Supreme Court’s explanation to see why several opinions can accompany one decision, and why the introductory syllabus is not itself an opinion written by the justices.
In the “Opinions” section, begin with the paragraph starting “The most well-known opinions are those released or announced.” Read the explanation through the sentence about the syllabus prepared by the Reporter of Decisions. Focus on the distinction between the opinions published together and the summary placed before them.
The writings share a case, but not necessarily a conclusion. A majority opinion states a result and reasoning that a majority of the participating justices join. A justice who agrees with the result may write separately to explain a different or additional reason; that writing is a concurring opinion. A justice who disagrees with the result may write a dissenting opinion, explaining why the Court should have decided differently.
An opinion is therefore more than a record of an individual vote. It shows what a justice thinks should happen to the case and why. Those two features provide the most reliable basis for classification.
First identify the judgment
The judgment is the Court’s formal disposition of the case before it. For this lesson, the essential point is whether the writer accepts that disposition. The details of what a disposition accomplishes for the parties—including what happens when a case is sent back to a lower court—come later in the course.
Watch this short explanation of how agreement about a result can coexist with disagreement about reasons.
Supreme Court of the United States Procedures: Crash Course Government and Politics #20
Watch Supreme Court of the United States Procedures from CrashCourse for a compact introduction to concurrences and dissents.
Watch concurring opinions for the distinction between an outcome and its rationale. Then watch dissenting opinions for how a justice who opposes the outcome can state a competing view. For now, focus on classification; the course will examine holdings and precedent more closely in later lessons.
A useful first pass through an excerpt is to find its disposition language. “I would affirm” and “I would reverse” indicate what the writer wants done with the lower court’s decision. “I agree with the Court’s judgment” signals agreement with the result. “I respectfully dissent” signals opposition, though the surrounding text still matters if the writer dissents only in part.
Agreement with the judgment does not establish agreement with the majority’s reasoning. That is why a concurrence can sit alongside a majority opinion even though both writers favor the same result.
Then identify whose reasoning the passage gives
Suppose the Court concludes that a school cannot sustain the suspensions of students who wore silent protest armbands. The following passages are invented illustrations, not quotations from the historical case discussed in the previous lesson:
Opinion of the Court: “We set aside the suspensions. The school has not shown a sufficient basis for expecting the armbands to materially disrupt its work.”
Separate opinion: “I agree that the suspensions must be set aside. I would decide only that the school cannot single out these armbands while allowing comparable expressions; I would not reach the broader disruption question.”
Separate opinion: “I would uphold the suspensions. School officials had adequate grounds to anticipate disorder and should not have to wait for it to occur.”
The first passage presents both the Court’s result and the reasoning offered on its behalf: it is the majority opinion, assuming a majority of the justices joined that reasoning. The second supports the same result but proposes a different, narrower basis: it is a concurrence. The third would give the school the opposite result: it is a dissent.
Notice that classifying the second passage does not require choosing which legal rationale is stronger. The writer’s relationship to the judgment comes first. Nor should the dissent be classified merely because its tone is critical. A concurrence can criticize the majority’s reasoning quite sharply while agreeing that the majority reached the right result.
OpenStax gives a short account of how majority support and separate writing fit together.
Read the “Judicial Opinions” subsection to reinforce the distinction between an opinion joined by a majority and a separate opinion from a justice who agrees with the outcome.
Under “JUDICIAL OPINIONS,” read the opening paragraphs, ending with the definition of a concurring opinion. Pay particular attention to the sentences beginning “The Supreme Court’s decisions are not always unanimous” and “If a justice agrees with the outcome.” The subsection opens with a broad statement about precedent; do not take it to mean that a dissent supplies a binding rule. The role of different opinions as precedent is addressed later in the course.
A concurrence need not reject all of the majority’s reasoning. Its author might agree with much of the majority opinion but write separately to add a qualification. The expression “concurring in the judgment” is especially useful: it tells you that the writer accepts what the Court does with the case while offering a separate account of why.
Use labels as evidence, not as a substitute for reading
When you have the full published opinions, headings and introductory lines often make classification straightforward. “Opinion of the Court” identifies a writing presented on the Court’s behalf; “concurring” and “dissenting” identify separate opinions. Still, the substance helps you understand the label—and protects you when an excerpt omits its heading.
Read an unfamiliar passage in this order:
- Locate the Court’s judgment, if the excerpt or its context supplies it.
- Locate the writer’s preferred result. Does the writer accept that judgment or propose a different one?
- Compare the reasoning. If the writer accepts the judgment but gives a separate explanation, the passage is from a concurrence. If the writer rejects the judgment, it is from a dissent. To identify a majority opinion, look for evidence that the writing states reasoning joined by a majority, such as its heading or an accompanying list of justices who joined it.
The third step prevents an easy mistake. A bare sentence such as “I would set aside the suspensions” reveals a preferred result, but cannot by itself distinguish a majority opinion from a concurrence. Both may favor setting the suspensions aside. You need the Court’s stated result and information about whether the writer speaks for the majority or writes separately.
The reverse mistake is to treat every disagreement with the majority as a dissent. Consider: “I agree with today’s judgment, but the Court’s rule reaches further than this case requires.” That writer criticizes the reasoning yet accepts the result, so the passage signals a concurrence. By contrast, “I agree that the school faced a difficult choice, but I would uphold its policy” would be a dissent if the Court struck the policy down. A dissent can acknowledge points made by the majority without joining its judgment.
Some opinions combine positions: a justice may concur in part and dissent in part when a case contains several issues or rulings. In such an excerpt, specify which part of the judgment the writer accepts or opposes rather than forcing the entire writing into a simpler category. Likewise, if an excerpt supplies neither its heading nor enough context to establish the Court’s judgment, the sound classification is not enough information.
Why the distinction matters
The majority, concurrence, and dissent can discuss the same facts yet answer different legal questions—or answer the same question with different reasoning. Reading only the vote count can conceal that difference. Several justices may agree about who wins while disagreeing about how broadly the decision should be explained.
The distinction also keeps separate opinions in their proper place. A concurrence may offer an approach later courts find persuasive, and a dissent may preserve an argument for a future case. Neither becomes the Court’s majority reasoning merely because it is published beside it. To work out what legal rule the Court established, you must read the majority’s reasoning with care—a task that begins with distinguishing its holding from other statements in the next lesson.
Key takeaways
Classify an excerpt on two axes: result and reasoning. A majority opinion gives the Court’s judgment and reasoning supported by a majority. A concurrence accepts the judgment but writes separately about the reasons. A dissent opposes the judgment, even if it agrees with some points along the way. When the heading or the Court’s result is missing, avoid claiming more certainty than the excerpt permits.
Next, you will look within an opinion to distinguish the holding that resolves the case from comments that do not form part of that holding.