Skip to main content

Welcome to a Grasp lesson

Create a free account to keep studying and create your own study path.

Lesson 1

Classifying Candidate-Election Spending Types

Recommended resources

Campaign-finance stories often call any money spent to help a candidate a “donation.” In federal candidate elections, that shorthand hides a distinction that will matter throughout this course: giving value to a campaign, paying for your own advocacy, and paying for advocacy with a campaign’s involvement are not the same transaction.

This first lesson builds a way to classify those transactions. Later lessons will use the classifications to explain why courts treat contribution limits and independent-spending restrictions differently, what Citizens United decided, and how to assess new state restrictions. Allow about 40 minutes, including the two short Federal Election Commission readings.


Start with the recipient, not the amount

Suppose a supporter writes a check to a candidate’s authorized campaign committee. The campaign receives the money and decides how to use it. That is a direct contribution. The amount might be small or large; the transaction’s category depends first on where the value goes, not how much it is.

A contribution need not be cash. If a supporter buys office supplies for the campaign and gives them to it, the supplies provide value to the campaign. That is ordinarily an in-kind contribution. The same principle applies when someone pays a campaign expense on its behalf. Calling such a payment “spending” does not make it independent spending: the campaign still receives the benefit of a good or service supplied for it.

Read the FEC’s explanation before moving to advertisements. It establishes why both a check and a donated service can fall on the contribution side of the line.

FEC | Candidate | Types of contributions

Read the Federal Election Commission’s “Types of contributions” for its basic definition of a contribution and its treatment of goods, services, and coordinated communications.

At the start of “Types of contributions,” read the definition, then the “Money” subsection under “Gifts of money and loans.” In “In-kind contributions,” read the “Definition” subsection from goods through spending. Finally, find “Coordinated communications” near the end of “In-kind contributions” and read its classification rule. Focus on who receives the value, even when no money changes hands with the campaign.

The FEC notes a limited party-committee exception to its description of coordinated communications. For the simple transactions in this lesson, the central rule is that a third party’s coordinated candidate advertisement is generally treated as an in-kind contribution—not as independent advocacy.



An advertisement can support a candidate without being given to the campaign

Now change the facts. A supporter pays a printer to display a billboard urging voters to elect a named candidate. The supporter chooses its message, location, and timing without consulting or cooperating with the candidate or campaign. The money goes to the printer, not the campaign. The billboard is an independent expenditure: spending on a communication that expressly advocates the election or defeat of a clearly identified candidate and is made independently of the candidate and relevant campaign or party actors.

An FEC example of a billboard urging a vote for a candidate. Its notice identifies an outside payer and says the advertisement was not authorized by a candidate or candidate committee.

The billboard makes the electoral message easy to identify: it tells viewers to vote for a particular person. Its notice also illustrates what an outside sponsor tells the public about payment and authorization. The notice alone is not proof that the spending was independent. Classification depends on what actually happened between the payer and the campaign, a distinction we will return to below.

“Independent expenditure” is a specific federal-law category, not a synonym for every political message paid for outside a campaign. Its communication must expressly advocate election or defeat. A direct “Vote for this candidate” appeal qualifies. An issue advertisement that merely mentions a candidate does not automatically become an independent expenditure; other rules may still apply to it.

FEC | Making independent expenditures

Read the Federal Election Commission’s “Making independent expenditures” for the two defining features of this category: electoral advocacy and independence from the campaign.

In “Definitions,” read the two-part definition. Continue through “Clearly identified candidate.” In “Express advocacy,” read the examples under “Explicit words of advocacy of election or defeat,” beginning at the examples. Then read the “‘Only reasonable interpretation’ test,” from the alternative test through the explanation that follows it. Focus on why an unmistakable electoral appeal need not use the exact words “vote for.”

The independence requirement concerns the relationship between the outside spender and the campaign, not whether the advertisement helps the candidate. An effective independent advertisement may help a candidate enormously. Conversely, an advertisement can fail to be independent even if its sponsor pays the printer directly and never transfers a dollar to the campaign.



Coordination changes how outside spending is treated

Consider a third version of the billboard. An outside group offers to pay for it, and the candidate’s campaign asks the group to place it in a particular area shortly before election day. The group pays the printer, but the campaign has influenced the advertisement. Under the applicable federal coordinated-communication rules, such spending is treated as a contribution to the candidate, generally an in-kind contribution. The group’s payment of the printer does not preserve independence.

There is a reason to distinguish coordination from mere agreement about a candidate. A supporter can independently watch a candidate’s public speech, decide that the candidate deserves support, and buy an advertisement. Shared political preferences do not themselves show that the campaign participated in the spending decision. At the other extreme, a campaign request for a particular advertisement is powerful evidence of the involvement that defeats independence.

For a federal coordinated communication, the FEC uses a three-part framework: payment by someone outside the relevant campaign or party committee, qualifying content, and qualifying conduct connecting the payer with a candidate or party. For instance, an outside-paid public advertisement expressly urging a vote for a federal candidate can meet the content component; a campaign request for that advertisement can meet a conduct component. These are legal criteria, not simply a judgment that two organizations look close. We will examine harder coordination scenarios later in the course.

FEC | Making independent expenditures

Return to the FEC’s “Making independent expenditures,” this time for its explanation of coordination. Read for the structure of the test, not to memorize every type of advertisement or timing rule.

Find “Coordination defined” and read the definition. Under “Determining coordination,” read the three prongs. Skim “Payment prong” and “Content prong,” noting the listed standard for a public communication that expressly advocates a federal candidate’s election or defeat; you can leave the detailed timing rules for later. Under “Conduct prong,” read the “Request or suggestion” explanation beginning with campaign requests. Then, in “Material involvement,” read the campaign decisions that can matter, such as audience and timing.

Formal paperwork is not the dividing line. The FEC does not require a signed agreement before conduct can count as coordination. At the same time, a shared goal of electing a candidate is not, by itself, enough to establish a coordinated communication. The relevant facts concern payment, the message, and the interaction behind its creation or distribution.



A classification you can carry into the next lesson

The three core transactions can be kept distinct without assuming that all election money is unlimited:

Transaction Initial classification Decisive feature
A supporter sends money to a candidate’s campaign Direct contribution The campaign receives the money.
A supporter independently pays for an advertisement expressly urging election of a named candidate Independent expenditure The payer funds its own electoral message without campaign coordination.
An outside group pays for that advertisement at the campaign’s request Coordinated spending, generally an in-kind contribution The outside payment is connected to qualifying campaign involvement.

A donation to an outside organization is a fourth kind of transaction. It is not itself the organization’s independent expenditure; the expenditure occurs when the organization spends on qualifying advocacy. We will trace that funding route when we reach PACs and super PACs.

The practical habit is to establish the facts before applying a label: identify who paid, who received value, what the communication said, and whether the campaign took part. Those facts explain why two advertisements with identical words can fall into different categories. In the next lesson, we will examine why the First Amendment makes restrictions on these forms of political support constitutionally significant.