Welcome back. The previous lesson separated a larger TEFA award from a child’s entitlement to special-education services. A similar separation is needed when a news claim says vouchers either “save public schools money” or “take money from every public school.” State TEFA spending, state school-funding savings, and a district’s operating budget are different quantities. This lesson uses a worked scenario and the Legislative Budget Board’s April 24, 2025 fiscal note to show how they can move differently.
Three budgets hidden in one claim
A TEFA award is a state program expense. If a child leaves a public school, the state may later spend less through the Foundation School Program (FSP). The former school district may also lose enrollment-related revenue—but some of its expenses will remain even after the child leaves. These amounts need not equal one another.
The April 24, 2025 Legislative Budget Board (LBB) fiscal note estimates the bill’s state-budget effects. It is a forecast for SB 2 as passed by the second house, not a record of actual participation or a district-by-district budget study. Its first page projects a $1 billion negative impact to General Revenue–related funds for the 2026–27 biennium. It also says the bill itself would make no appropriation: the Legislature would have to provide funding, within the bill’s initial biennial spending limit. Later-year figures depend on future funding decisions.
legislative budget board - Texas Legislature Online
Read this official fiscal note to establish what its headline costs measure—and what they do not.
On pp. 1–2, begin with the estimated two-year impact and read through the five-year tables and the paragraph in “Fiscal Analysis” ending with the initial biennial limit: costs and limit. Notice the distinction between a bill that permits a program, a legislative appropriation, and projected annual costs. In the “All Funds, Five-Year Impact” table, keep the General Revenue cost and Foundation School Fund savings in separate columns.
The table illustrates the timing issue. The note projects approximately $989.4 million in General Revenue cost in fiscal year 2027, with no FSP savings shown that year. For fiscal year 2028, it projects about $3.330 billion in General Revenue cost and $257.5 million in FSP savings, yielding a net General Revenue–related impact of about negative $3.072 billion. The note attributes the delay in FSP savings to the following fiscal year’s settle-up process. Its 2028 figure is a conditional projection, not a spending authorization already guaranteed for that year.
Which children generate which effects?
The child’s previous enrollment matters. A public-school switcher may generate both a TEFA cost and a later FSP saving because the child no longer generates public-school funding in the same way. A child already in private school can generate a TEFA cost without leaving a public-school seat. The same is true of a child who continues homeschooling, although SB 2 limits that child’s annual account transfer to $2,000. A child moving from homeschooling into private school is a different case: that child may receive the applicable private-school award but still was not a public-school switcher.
SB 2 also requires checks that a participating child is not enrolled in a public school in a manner that counts the child toward average daily attendance (ADA) for FSP funding. If a participant returns to public school during a school year, the law provides for public-school funding for that child and an additional allotment specified in the statute. Enrollment is therefore not necessarily a permanent one-way movement.
Use the enrolled bill to check the legal rules behind the fiscal categories, rather than treating the fiscal note’s assumptions as law.
In § 29.361(a), (b), and (b-1), pp. 21–22, read from the general award percentage through the homeschool limit: transfer rules. Then read § 29.3611, pp. 23–24, from the child’s departure from TEFA through its public-school funding and accountability provisions: return provision. Finally, in § 29.362(d), pp. 25–26, read from the organization’s duty to check enrollment through the notification concerning private-school enrollment: enrollment check. Focus on why an account transfer is not itself a payment to the child’s former district.
The LBB model makes these enrollment categories explicit, but its counts are assumptions. It assumes private-school capacity can expand by ten percent of then-current enrollment each year, with 70 percent of added places filled by public-school students and 30 percent by homeschool students moving into private school. That produces an estimated 24,500 public-school switchers in fiscal year 2027. It separately estimates applications from children already in private school and from children who would continue homeschooling. Applicants are not necessarily funded participants, especially under a spending limit.
legislative budget board - Texas Legislature Online
Read the model’s assumptions and its narrower statement about local public-school budgets.
Under “Methodology,” pp. 3–4, read the private-school-capacity assumptions from the estimated current private-school enrollment through the projected homeschool-to-private-school count: capacity assumptions. Read the projected award amounts from the fiscal-year-2027 general estimate through the statement that estimates use current-law formulas: award estimates. Continue through the projected homeschool and existing-private-school applications: application estimates. On p. 4, read the estimated FSP saving per public-school switcher and its delayed realization: state savings. Finally, under “Local Government Impact,” pp. 4–5, read the discussion beginning with a possible decrease in local education agencies’ FSP funding through the uncertainty about students returning to public school: local impact. Keep projected applications, projected switchers, and funded awards distinct.
For fiscal year 2027 switchers, the note estimates $10,512 in FSP savings per student, realized in the following fiscal year. Its approximately $257.5 million fiscal-year-2028 saving is consistent with the estimated 24,500 switchers multiplied by roughly that per-student amount; the published figures are rounded. Crucially, $10,512 is an estimated state FSP saving, not a measured loss of $10,512 to every district for every departing child. In its “Local Government Impact” section, the note says local education agencies may experience decreased FSP funding, while the number leaving depends on capacity, appropriations, and families’ choices.
A worked budget scenario
Consider a deliberately simplified fiscal-year-2027 cohort. Assume funding is available and all of these fictional children receive awards. To make the arithmetic transparent, assume a $10,000 award for each participating child attending private school and a $2,000 award for each child continuing to homeschool. These are scenario inputs, not the official award calculation for a particular school year or an assertion that all applicants will be funded.
| Prior situation and TEFA choice | Children | Assumed award each | Illustrative state TEFA transfers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Public school; switches to private school | 100 | $10,000 | $1,000,000 |
| Already in private school; stays there | 60 | $10,000 | $600,000 |
| Already homeschooling; continues homeschooling | 40 | $2,000 | $80,000 |
| Total | 200 | $1,680,000 |
The $1.68 million is gross state account spending for this cohort, excluding administration and other effects. Only the 100 public-school switchers are candidates for the kind of FSP saving estimated in the fiscal note. Applying its fiscal-year-2027 per-switcher estimate for illustration gives about $1,051,200 in state FSP savings in the following fiscal year (). Subtracting that from $1.68 million would give about $628,800 across these selected effects, but not a complete net cost for either fiscal year: the transfers and savings occur at different times, and the example omits later awards, administration, and other changes.
Now view the same 100 switchers from one hypothetical district’s perspective. Suppose its annual operating revenue falls by $9,000 per departing child, while it can avoid $3,000 per child in costs during that year. Neither number is supplied by the LBB note; both are explicit assumptions for this district.
The district’s budget position worsens by $600,000 under these assumptions, even though it serves fewer children and avoids some costs. A bus route, building, or class may not become proportionately cheaper when a small number of students leave; greater enrollment losses might eventually permit larger changes. Conversely, a different district’s revenue rules, enrollment pattern, and avoidable costs could yield another result. The 60 existing private-school students and 40 continuing homeschoolers cause no departure from this district in the scenario. Their TEFA awards should not be counted as losses of its enrollment-related revenue.
This is why the state’s estimated $1,051,200 FSP saving and the district’s assumed $900,000 revenue decline are kept on separate ledgers. The first uses an LBB statewide modeling assumption and a later fiscal-year settle-up; the second is a fictional district-specific change in operating revenue. Equating either one with the $1.68 million in state TEFA transfers would conceal both who participated and which budget changed.
Reading a disputed budget claim precisely
A claim that “every TEFA dollar comes out of a public school” fails for existing private-school and continuing homeschool participants: their awards cost the state, but they did not leave a public school to participate. A claim that “TEFA pays for itself whenever a student switches” also goes beyond the evidence: the state incurs an award and may later realize an FSP saving, while the district’s revenue can fall faster than its avoidable costs. Neither slogan specifies the participant mix, time period, or budget being measured.
The April 24, 2025 note supplies a disciplined starting point, not an observed final result. Its private-school-capacity growth, applicant counts, switcher counts, award averages, and delayed savings are forecasts. Its estimates after the initial biennium expressly depend on future legislative funding. For a later claim, identify the fiscal year and bill or law version, then replace model assumptions with dated participation, appropriation, and district data where available.
What to retain
TEFA transfers are state costs; FSP savings arise chiefly from modeled public-school switchers and may appear later; district effects depend on lost revenue minus avoidable costs. Existing private-school and continuing homeschool participants can add state cost without causing a public-school departure. In the worked scenario, those distinctions produce a state transfer total, a delayed estimated state saving, and a separate district operating effect—not one interchangeable “cost per student.”
The next module turns from budget claims to practical access. Its first lesson examines whether an eligible household can actually use an award, given tuition gaps, transportation, available places, admissions, and disability services.